|
Report:
Did SARS come from
cats?
Investigators: Corrie Brown and
Jacqueline Katz
20 May 2003
by Tabitha M. Powledge
Severe acute
respiratory syndrome (SARS) may have
jumped to humans from cats, says a
microbiologist. And because three out
of four new human diseases have their
origins in animals, more of these
SARS-like epidemics are inevitable,
she warns.
The emergence of SARS and other novel
human diseases in Asia is frequently
attributed to the proximity of humans to
their livestock. But, says Corrie Brown,
professor at the University of Georgia
College of Veterinary Medicine in Athens,
human-livestock cohabitation occurs in many
places that are not noted for new disease,
such as Latin America. "It's a dogma we've
accepted without proof," she said.
More human diseases will come from our
pets, predicted Brown. "Maybe SARS is an
example of that," she speculated. Perhaps a
cat acted as initial mixing vessel for
combining noninfective existing viruses into
something that could make people very sick
and even kill them, she says
There is much speculation that SARS
jumped to people from domestic poultry, but
no molecular evidence backs it up, agreed
Jacqueline Katz, chief of the immunology and
viral pathology section of the influenza
branch at the Centers for Disease Control
and Protection (CDC).
However, as microbiologists grapple with
the question of why emerging diseases so
often do their emerging in Asia, Katz said
that the continent's enormous population,
its crowding, and the common practice of
living near livestock, especially poultry
are likely to be part of the answer. Live
bird markets are perfect for transmitting
viruses from poultry to humans, she says.
Whatever the origin of SARS, there is
little doubt that domestic poultry viruses
can cause fatal human respiratory disease.
The 1997 Hong Kong outbreak of avian flu in
humans was stopped in its tracks by
slaughtering millions of chickens in Hong
Kong markets, said Katz.
A different kind of avian flu sickened
two people in Hong Kong in February and
killed one of them. Its origin is not clear.
The affected family might have caught it
from chickens on a New Year visit to the
mainland or perhaps from wild aquatic birds
- infected birds have been found in Hong
Kong parks.
Owing to the dominance of SARS in the
news, two other new avian flu strains have
been wreaking havoc in the past few weeks
without much media attention. One has turned
up on turkey farms in Connecticut and is
creating problems for the US Department of
Agriculture, says Katz.
The other is a virulent strain of poultry
flu, which appeared in the Netherlands at
the end of February. It soon jumped directly
from Dutch birds to Dutch pigs, and has also
been conveyed to humans, probably by an
infected poultry worker, she said.
In humans, this new bird virus has caused
conjunctivitis - 82 cases to date. Some
patients also suffered respiratory illness,
but there's no hard evidence that this
symptom was caused by the virus. The disease
has now spread to Belgium and Germany, and
has cost 100,000 Euros to treat in less than
3 months.
The gaps in so-called species barriers
are wide and deep, concludes Brown.
Practically all carnivore diseases affect
more than one species, she says, as do 60%
of livestock diseases. Furthermore, there is
still almost nothing known about pathogens
in wild animals.
Around 75% of new human diseases are
zoonotic, says Brown. Of some 1400 known
human pathogens, 60% came from animals. And
the traffic is two-way, she says, with
humans sharing many of their diseases with
animals. Examples include tuberculosis and
transmission of
Giardia to bears in Yosemite Park.
"There is so much out there that we have a
lot of job security," Brown told fellow
microbiologists. |