U.S. Denies
Changing Smallpox Vaccine Policy
Refutes news report on 'about-face'
for health, emergency workers
By Adam Marcus
HealthScoutNews Reporter
THURSDAY, May 8 (HealthScoutNews)
-- The Bush administration is denying a news
report that its smallpox vaccine policy for
health and emergency workers has changed.
CBS News reported Wednesday night
that the federal government had done an
"about-face" and was now allowing states to
suspend or stop vaccinating civilians
against the deadly virus, which has been
eradicated but is a highly feared weapon of
bioterrorism.
Administration officials say states have
always had the option of how to run their
end of the program with the controversial
and potentially harmful vaccine.
"U.S. policy has not changed since we
announced it in December of 2002," says Bill
Pierce, a spokesman for the Department of
Health and Human Services (HHS). "The
program has always been voluntary, with our
guidance."
So far, Pierce adds, no state has bowed
out of the plan. However, some hospitals and
individuals have declined to participate.
And several states have suspended their
vaccination programs in response to concerns
over heart-related side effects from the
inoculation.
When it announced the vaccine policy late
last year, the U.S. government called for a
two-phase, voluntary strategy for civilians.
In the first stage, roughly 450,000
health-care and emergency workers would
receive the vaccine, followed by a second
round covering up to 10 million other
so-called "first responders" in the event of
a bioterror attack with the virus.
At the time, HHS Secretary Tommy Thompson
said he expected states to proceed quickly
between the two phases. However, an
independent advisory panel has consistently
urged that states pause to evaluate the
safety of the vaccine, which can cause
deadly reactions in rare cases.
"Our feeling was it was very important
that there be a pause between phase one and
phase two to learn from the experience,"
says Dr. Brian Strom, head of the Institute
of Medicine panel advising the federal
government on the smallpox vaccine plan.
"Our recommendation is that the length of
the pause be determined by data rather than
by an arbitrary time frame," adds Strom, of
the University of Pennsylvania School of
Medicine.
Between Jan. 24 and the last week of
April, 34,541 civilian health workers
voluntarily received the smallpox vaccine,
far fewer than the number officials had
projected.
The government has received 55 reports of
serious adverse reactions to the smallpox
vaccine among civilians and is investigating
at least three heart attack deaths -- two
civilian and one military -- possibly linked
to the inoculation. The vaccine has also
caused 413 cases of mild complications, such
as fevers, rashes and headaches, according
to a report in the May 9 Morbidity and
Mortality Weekly Report, which was
released Thursday by the CDC.
Of the serious problems among civilians
who received the vaccine, 15 involved
myopericarditis, a potentially
life-threatening heart inflammation. Another
17 cases of the inflammation had been
identified in soldiers through late last
month, Strom says.
More information
Learn about smallpox and the vaccination
from the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
or the
Department of Defense.
Copyright © 2003 ScoutNews, LLC. All rights
reserved.
|