|
Report:
Gators gauge endocrine
exposure
Investigator: Louis Guillette
21 June 2003
by Bea Perks
They might
not be the most compliant study
subjects, but alligators are helping
one endocrinologist to work out the
long-term endocrine consequences of
exposure to common environmental
contaminants. His findings could have
important implications for other
animals, not least humans
"Instead of talking about wild types,
we're talking about real wild animals," said
Louis Guillette of the University of
Florida's Department of Zoology, "and when
we talk about knockouts we don't normally
mean gene knockouts."
Florida fishermen began detecting
irregularities in the local American
alligator (Alligator
mississippiensis) population almost
20 years ago, and brought in Guillette to
investigate the reproductive biology of
these animals.
Guillette duly set upon the intrepid
task, which involves hanging off the front
of airboats in Florida's lakes and capturing
reptilian subjects for investigation. "It's
a little different to the recruitment that
you all do for your patients," Guillette
told an audience of clinical
endocrinologists.
He found that male and female alligators
in some lakes had abnormal levels of
circulating sex hormones. Males in these
lakes had elevated levels of estradiol and
reduced levels of testosterone - similar to
levels normally measured in females.
Females also had elevated levels of
estradiol, almost twice what is normally
seen, but once they reached puberty they had
depressed levels of the hormone. Many of
these females also had polyovular follicles,
which are associated with increased rates of
infertility and embryonic loss, and are
generally the result of estrogen exposure
during embryonic or neonatal life.
"The problem is, my animals aren't taking
pharmaceutics," said Guillette. "So where in
the world is this estrogen signal coming
from?"
He has been detecting the most profound
changes in alligator hormone levels and
fertility at Lake Apopca, which lies just
outside Orlando and is surrounded by an area
of heavy agricultural activity; it also
suffered a pesticide spill just over 20
years ago.
Chemical analysis of the water there has
revealed relatively high levels of
persistent organofluorine pesticides,
including two major metabolites of the
notorious pesticide DDT, widely banned
around the world but still used in many
tropical countries.
In unpublished work, Guillette has now
begun to measure elevated levels of these
contaminants, and others, in alligator eggs
collected from nests on the lakeside. One
DDT metabolite in particular, named
p,p'-DDE, was detected at 10-15 parts per
million, putting it on a physiologically
relevant microgram scale. p,p'-DDE turns out
to compete with estrogen binding for its
receptor, says Guillette, making it a potent
anti-androgen.
Sex differentiation in alligators has one
marked difference to sex in mammals.
Temperature determines alligator gender -
there is no X and Y chromosome or
equivalent. If you incubate an egg at 30oC
for a three-day period, at six weeks
gestation, says Guillette, you get 100%
females. If you incubate at 33-35oC
you get 100% males.
He has found that if he incubates
alligator eggs at the "male-producing
temperature", but exposes them to an
estrogen (by applying it to the shell), he
can redirect sex determination and end up
with a female. "This is an all or none," he
said. "You don't get hermaphrodites."
His team has now incubated eggs at 32.5oC,
which normally gives a low frequency of
females, and treated them with increasing
doses of the apparently estrogenic
contaminants identified in Lake Apopca. His
results are surprising. "We're getting these
weird dose-response curves," he said.
Increasing contaminant concentration does
not necessarily result in the production of
more females. "These compounds aren't acting
as full agonists, they appear to be
producing both an estrogenic and an
anti-estrogenic response," he said.
In addition, Guillette has found that
when eggs are treated with levels of
contaminants, such as p,p'-DDE, that are
insufficient to cause a change of sex, there
are nonetheless changes in gonad function
that persist well beyond gestation. The
testes of these individuals may still look
like testes, he says, but they can secrete
hormones as though they were ovaries.
"We're starting to get some idea that
early exposure to contaminants that have the
potential to act as estrogens have long-term
consequences beyond just the developing
embryo," he said.
The alligator provides a very useful way
of monitoring endocrine consequences of
environmental contaminants. "No matter how
much estrogen you give a developing baby boy
you're not going to turn it into a baby
girl, like I could do with an alligator,"
said Guillette.
"The phenotype that we see in organisms,
and in this case we've shown you alligators
but I would argue that it's probably a large
number of organisms including ourselves, is
not just the product of our genes and it's
not just the environment that we
traditionally think about, like nutrition
and maybe photoperiod etc., but the
environment is also composed of contaminants
that have endocrine action." |