AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals LP pleaded guilty yesterday to
conspiring to encourage doctors to bill for a prostate cancer drug
that the company provided free, and agreed to pay $355 million to
settle civil and criminal charges.
The London-based company admitted that it gave thousands of
samples of the drug Zoladex to urologists knowing that the doctors
would prescribe the injectable medication and then bill Medicare,
Medicaid and other health insurance providers, according to the
Justice Department and the Food and Drug Administration.
AstraZeneca cost Medicare and others almost $40 million, the
Justice Department said. Most of the money, $291 million, will
settle civil charges. The rest will be paid as a criminal fine.
"We accept responsibility for any improper sampling conduct that
took place in the mid-1990s and have taken steps within our new
company to prevent such activities from happening again,"
AstraZeneca said yesterday in a written statement. The samples were
given out by Zeneca Inc., which merged with Astra-Merck to form
AstraZeneca in 1999.
AstraZeneca's guilty plea is a result of one of the largest
health fraud investigations the federal government has undertaken.
In 2001, TAP Pharmaceutical Products Inc. of Lake Forest, Ill., paid
$875 million to settle charges that it conspired with doctors to
bill federal health programs for free samples of its prostate cancer
drug, Lupron, in the mid-1990s.
The AstraZeneca and TAP settlements are the results of
accusations made by whistle-blower Douglas N. Durand, the former
vice president of sales for TAP. As an executive, Durand had access
to letters between a division of TAP and Zeneca that documented how
the companies defrauded Medicare, Durand said in an interview.
"It was egregious, the behaviors of both companies, in terms of
fraud against consumers," said Durand, who filed a civil False
Claims Act suit against the companies and will receive more than
$125 million under the settlements.
Durand said each company knew of the other's illegal sales
methods and kept a "peaceful coexistence."
"They would send these letters every year. You want to talk about
a smoking gun, these letters were a smoking gun for both companies,
especially for Zeneca," Durand said.
AstraZeneca also settled, without admitting liability, civil
charges that it provided inducements to doctors for purchasing
Zoladex and for improperly setting and reporting its price.
Prosecutors had alleged that the company engaged in a practice known
as "marketing the spread," in which a company sells its product to
doctors at prices below the Medicare reimbursement and allow the
doctor to keep the difference.
A statement prepared by the Justice Department said AstraZeneca
also made illegal payments for "unrestricted educational grants,
business assistance grants and services, travel and entertainment"
to promote the sale of Zoladex.
"This is very significant," said Assistant U.S. Attorney Beth
Moskow-Schnoll, who led the government's criminal prosecution of
AstraZeneca. "Hopefully this should send a message that doctors
should be prescribing drugs based on what the patient needs and not
on what their bottom line is."
Although Medicare doesn't pay for most drugs, it does cover some,
such as Zoladex and Lupron, that have to be injected by a doctor.
According to IMS Health, Lupron had sales of about $580 million last
year, and Zoladex about $233 million.
AstraZeneca pleaded guilty to violating the Prescription Drug
Marketing Act by providing the free samples to doctors from 1993 to
1996. No company officials were charged.
Before the guilty plea was announced yesterday, three physicians
were charged, and two pleaded guilty, to a conspiracy to bill for
the Zoladex samples.
Mark B. McClellan, the U.S. commissioner of food and drugs, said
yesterday that his agency is increasing its efforts to keep drug
manufacturers honest and costs under control. The cost of
prescription drugs is a central issue in the current congressional
debate over expanding Medicare coverage to prescription drugs.
"Today's announcement sends a strong message that the FDA will
enforce the laws and take vigorous actions against those who defraud
consumers and abuse the health care system," he said.