* IDEA ALERT - Your Feedback Needed on Senate
Bill 1248!
* Hall of Fame Teachers San Jose Domain -
Teachers Success Rewarded
RESEARCH
* Parent Autism Research Funding Group
Commits Nearly $5 million
ADVOCACY
* MMR: 1,500 UK Families To Sue
LITERATURE
* Curious Incident of the Dog in the
Night-Time
The Remains of the Dog
LETTER
* A Simple Test for the Need to Vaccinate
PUBLIC HEALTH
CDCs Online Telecast On Autism - Friday, 6/20
The Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC) is co-hosting a unique Public Health Grand Rounds satellite
telecast on autism. The program, entitled Autism Among Us: Rising Concerns and
the Public Health Response will air on Friday, June 20, 2003, at 2:00-3:00 pm
Eastern Time.
Part of the public health response to
autism is early identification, which leads to early intervention and a much
better prognosis for children who are diagnosed with an autism spectrum disorder
(ASD). To do this, public health professionals must be aware of the signs of
autism and be able to connect children and their families with community
resources.
If you work with children and their
parents, you cant afford to miss this program, because you cant afford to miss
autism. The earlier we in pubic health can find it and the more effectively we
can educate, refer, and support, the more we can reduce the grave burden of this
growing problem. - Hugh Tilson, MD, DrPH Registration allows you to suggest
questions for the expert panel and also enables the program planners to assess
the impact of this program, which is the basis for continued funding. Public
Health Grand Rounds is an innovative broadcast and Webcast series offered at no
cost to
the participant. After each program, an online
evaluation with a comment
section is offered so that we may continuously
improve the Grand Rounds series. Your feedback is valuable and has been the
cornerstone of these programs.
For more information and the opportunity
to view past programs, visit our Website at:
http://www.PublicHealthGrandRounds.unc.edu If you need assistance, please
call us at 919.843.9261 or email GrandRounds@sph.unc.edu. Thank you for your
continued support, Donna E. Davis, MPH Grand Rounds Project Director
[Brief commentary: Heres an opportunity
for the autism community to be heard. Even if you cannot participate, you can
register and respond to survey questions that will require in the input of the
parent community. I encourage everyone to let our voices be heard on behalf of
our children. -LS.]
IDEA ALERT - Your Feedback Needed on Senate Bill
1248!
[From Pete and Pam Wright Wrightslaw & The
Special Ed Advocate newsletter.]
The Senate version of the Individuals with
Disabilities Education Act was introduced on Thursday, June 12, 2003. You can
read a five-page summary of Senate Bill 1248 from National Association of
Protection and Advocacy
Meetings will be scheduled at 20-Minute
Intervals, from 10:00 am -- noon, and 1 PM - 6 PM on these days: Monday, June
16, 2003 Tuesday, June 17, 2003 - RALLY DAY! Wednesday, June 18, 2003 Thursday,
June 19, 2003 Meetings will be in the HELP Committee Conference room, 428
Dirksen Senate Office Building.
To schedule a meeting, please contact
Aaron Bishop at 202-224-6770. Please request a specific date and time, and
provide the number of people attending, group/organization name, and contact
information (email address and phone number) for the person who is scheduling
the meeting.
You may also contact Aaron by e-mail at
idea_feedback@labor.senate.gov In the subject line of your email, type: Aaron -
IDEA Feedback Meeting. He will confirm the meeting via email/phone.
The Committee encourages groups with
similar interests to schedule meetings together, if possible. Meeting times will
be scheduled on a first-come/first-serve basis, and the 20-minute time limit
will be strictly enforced.
Comments by Letter or Email
The Committee will also receive responses
to the bill via email at: idea_feedback@labor.senate.gov or by fax at
202-228-0929.
Emailed and faxed responses should be sent
to the attention of and titled Annie and Connie - IDEA Reauthorization
Feedback.
Please note that this email address and
fax number will only be available from Thursday, June 12, 2003 through Friday,
June 20, 2003.
The Committee Mark-up date is scheduled
for June 25th.
Learn about the IDEA Rally:
http://www.wrightslaw.com/news/2003/idea.rally.htm Your Role If you are the
parent of a child with a disability, you represent your childs interests. You
need to stay informed about changes to the law that may affect your child. If
you are a teacher or special education service provider, the reauthorized law is
likely to affect you and your job. We encourage you to read the Summary of IDEA
Senate Bill by NAPAS - this document will help you identify the strengths and
weaknesses of the bill. Please share your concerns with the Senators - they seem
to be open to feedback from parents. Please distribute this Alert:
http://www.wrightslaw.com/nltr/03/al.0616.htm
Tips for Writing Letters to Congress
Here are some tips about writing letters
to members of Congress.
1. Personal stories are important. Explain
how your child, or a child for whom you advocate, will be hurt by the proposed
changes. 2. Explain what you like or do not like about the proposed bill. Why
do you think part of this bill may harm children or lead to increased costs to
society if children with disabilities dont get the education they need to
prepare them for employment and independent living (§1400(d) Purposes of IDEA
statute) 3. Keep your letter short. Focus on
one or two key points. 4. Offer to follow-up with a phone call or visit. 5.
Send your letter by fax or email.
The HELP Committee will receive responses
to the bill via email at idea_feedback@labor.senate.gov or by fax at
202-228-0929. Emailed and faxed responses should be sent to the attention of and
titled Annie and Connie - IDEA Reauthorization Feedback.
Include your name and address at the top
of your letter and sign it. Thank you!
IDEA Reauthorization News As the IDEA
Reauthorization process unfolds, you need news, progress reports, and other
important information. Bookmark the IDEA Reauthorization News page
http://www.wrightslaw.com/news/idea2002.htm To learn more about the issues,
including reports, surveys and recommendations about how the law may be changed,
please visit the IDEA Resources page.
Subscription & Contact Info The Special Ed
Advocate is a free online newsletter about special education legal and advocacy
issues, cases, and tactics and strategies. Subscribers receive alerts about
new cases, events, and special offers on Wrightslaw books.
Free Newsletter - Contact Info Pete and
Pam Wright Wrightslaw & The Special Ed Advocate P. O. Box 1008 Deltaville, VA
23043 Website:
http://www.wrightslaw.com Email: newsletter@wrightslaw.com
* * *
EDUCATION
Hall of Fame Teachers San Jose Domain -
Teachers Success Rewarded Instructor departs from conventional wisdom by
integrating regular, special education students
It is a world of primary colors and
exclamation points, of crayons spilling out of their boxes, of fat puzzle pieces
that might fit together if you work at them long enough.
This is Larry Statlers scattered domain.
And within its ordered disorder, the 55-year-old San Jose teacher has developed
a unique system. At every table and counter and bookshelf, special education
students learn side by side with their general-education peers.
The program -- which Statler has named
Discovery -- does not entirely conform to the accepted wisdom of special
education. But in terms of student behavior and growth, everyone agrees that it
works.
It has brought the Santa Teresa Elementary
teacher numerous awards, including induction later this month into the exclusive
National Teachers Hall of Fame. Nationally, only five teachers a year gain entry
into the Emporia, Kan., center.
Mr. Statler has pretty high standards for
his kids -- he demands a lot of them, Ken Rains said. Rains daughter,
Kimberly, was a special education student under Statler 20 years ago. Today, she
volunteers as an aide in his classroom.
Shes really enjoyed it, but shes had to
work hard, too, Rains said.
Its been just a great experience.
Statler calls his approach to teaching the shining star theory, which he
applies to all students. If you have high expectations, theyre going to reach
for them. Discovery -- with students from kindergarten through second grade
dispersed in one large space -- places the children in small groups, based
partly on their constantly changing levels of ability. Each grade has its own
teacher, and several aides and volunteers are there to assist. Statler oversees
the entire process.
Parents can choose whether to send their
children to Statlers program or a more traditional classroom that segregates
the special education students from their general education peers. Discovery has
gained much renown throughout the Oak Grove school district, and its popular
among parents of both types of students.
I like that they go at their own pace,
says parent and weekly volunteer Debbie Martinez. Her son Jared is in the first
grade. Also, I like that hes exposed to others. Some kids might make fun, or
get scared of them. But Jared sees them as just another person. The most
difficult and challenging students in the district -- including those who suffer
from retardation, autism and speech and hearing difficulties -- come to
Statlers program. Although its a popular theory in education that autistic
students should not be exposed to distractions, the Discovery program places
them smack in the middle of Discoverys controlled chaos.
Unconventional Some of it flies in the
face of what a lot of experts recommend, Statler says. But he believes the
special education students learn more from the modeling of their peers and
classmates. Statler constantly circulates among the pods of teachers and
students. He is soft-spoken and genial, but no pushover. When he spots a student
doing nothing in particular, he firmly shepherds him to a table with a puzzle.
Heres your assignment for now, he says.
Later, he likens his job to that of an
orchestra director. We call it `the hum. As soon as someone is out of tune, I
can hear it. `A-B-Sea The special education students are included in every
activity, including a popular, annual collaboration with the Childrens Musical
Theater of San Jose. This year, the class -- which had studied oceanography all
year, transforming one entire adjoining room into a mock-sea -- took part in a
show called A-B-Sea. The effect of all this on the students is evident in the
class. Students work busily, side by side, with a minimum of fuss. On this June
day, one group is writing a story.
Can I borrow your raser? a girl asks
her classmate.
He happens to have a mostly pink,
almost-new eraser. He looks at it for a moment, knowing full well that at the
end of the school year, almost-new erasers do not exactly fall out of the sky or
jump from the A-B-Sea.
Ill give it back. I promise, she says.
He hands it over without a word; then he
trustingly turns back to his own work as she erases.
This is the best learning experience I
ever had, says Kim Makin, 20, a college student who returns to volunteer when
she has free time. I made some of the best friends I ever had here. Everyone
was so nurturing. One reason the room is so jam-packed with stuff is that
Statler is an inveterate grant-application-writer. I spend part of my Christmas
and spring and summer vacations writing grants, he said. Were always looking
for ways to obtain funding. Thats how the Hall of Fame nomination came about.
We nominate each other for awards -- really, mostly to see if we can get funds
for the program.
But holy mackerel, when you actually get
one, its kind of shocking. The hall has honored 60 teachers since its start in
1992, including Jaime Escalante, the Los Angeles math teacher profiled in the
movie Stand and Deliver. Induction brings $3,000 in cash and materials, and a
$1,000 scholarship for a district student who plans to pursue an education
degree.
Statler seems not quite sure what to make
of the honor. To be alongside Jaime Escalante, he says. He shakes his head at
the thought; then adds, I feel very lucky. His co-workers and students seem
to feel equally lucky. Amid the colors and confusion of the classroom, they
create their happy hum. Above them hangs a large banner. If they look up -- and
sometimes they do -- they can read it any time. It says, Children Like Flowers
Bloom At Different Times. And if you step back and look at the bobbing colors
and gentle motion, the figures could remind you of one whole fertile garden.
Parent Autism Research Funding Group Commits
Nearly $5 million National Alliance for Autism Researchs 2003 Awards Include 35
Pilot Studies & 15 Fellowships and Training Programs
[From an organization announcement.]
The National Alliance for Autism Research
(NAAR) has recently committed nearly $5 million to fund 50 research grants and
fellowships in the U.S., Canada and Europe focusing on a wide range of
disciplines, including the neurosciences, language and communication, behavioral
sciences, genetics and epidemiology.
The NAAR Board of Trustees approved this
years funding commitment following the seventh annual meeting of the
organizations Scientific Advisory Board. NAARs 2003 research commitment totals
$4.92 million and will fund 35 pilot studies, 13 pre- and post-doctoral
fellowships and two training programs.
This year, we received a total of 170
requests for funding, which represents an 75% increase in the amount of total
requests we received compared to last year, said Andy Shih, Ph.D., director of
Research and Programs at NAAR. It is encouraging to see that the scientific
community is recognizing NAAR as a resourceful partner for the development of
world class autism research projects.
NAAR-funded pilot studies and fellowships
have proven to be a sound investment. To date, research initially funded by NAAR
has made a dramatic impact on the autism research landscape in North America and
Europe and has been leveraged to attract more than $37 million in autism
research awards by the National Institutes of Health and other governmental
sources.
NAARs 2003 research commitment represents
an increase of approximately $800,000 over last years commitment. NAAR funds
autism research projects based on the recommendations of its prestigious
Scientific Advisory Board and its Lay Review Committee.
NAAR has been able to again increase its
funding commitment to autism research due to the remarkable support of its
donors and the amazing success of its Walk F.A.R. for NAAR autism research
walkathons and the dedicated volunteers who bring these events to life.
We are thrilled to announce our 2003
research awards and are grateful to the ever-growing number of supporters who
dedicate their talents and resources to our organization, said NAAR President
Prisca Chen Marvin. We remain committed to accelerating the pace of research
and elevating the caliber of the science, as it represents the best hope for our
loved ones and for future generations.
Including the 2003 research awards, NAAR
has now committed $14.9 million to directly fund 169 research grants and
fellowships worldwide - more than any other non-governmental organization in the
U.S.
NAARs 2003 Research Awards Pilot Studies
- $3.92 million Susan Birren, Ph.D.
Brandeis University (Waltham, MA)
Regulation of Cortical Synaptogenesis by Basal Forebrain Cholinergic Neurons.
Two-year award - $120,000 Patrick Bolton,
Ph.D.
The Institute of Psychiatry at Kings
College (London, England) Speech & Language Impairments and Autism Spectrum
Disorders: A Twin Study of the Links Two-year award - $119,083 Patrick Bolton,
Ph.D.
The Institute of Psychiatry at Kings
College (London, England) Event Related Potential & Behavioral Investigations
of Face Processing in Individuals with Tuberous Sclerosis and Autism Two-year
award - $113,011 Kenneth Campbell, Ph.D.
Childrens Hospital Research Foundation
(Cincinnati, OH) Genetic Control of Mammalian Amygdalar Development Two-year
award - $120,000 Alice Carter, Ph.D.
University of Massachusetts (Boston, MA)
Maternal Sensitivity, Joint Attention and Gains in Language Acquisition in
Toddlers Diagnosed with Autism Two-year award - $103,096 Manuel Casanova, M.D.
Medical College of Georgia (Augusta, GA)
Macroscopic Correlates of Minicolumnar Abnormalities in Autism Two-year award -
$120,000 Susan Christian, Ph.D.
University of Chicago (Chicago, IL)
Identifying Small Chromosomal Rearrangements in Autism Using Microarrays
Two-year award - $118,845 Antonio Convit, M.D.
New York University School of Medicine
(New York, NY) Social Cognition and Brain Volumes in Asperger Syndrome Two-year
award - $112,900 Thomas Cook, Ph.D.
Rutgers University (Piscataway, NJ)
Placental Metabolism & Fatty Acid Homeostasis in Fetal Imprinting of Autism and
Autism Spectrum Disorders Two-year award - $120,000 Michael Cuccaro, Ph.D.
Duke University Medical Center (Durham,
NC) Retrospective Association Analysis of Children with Idiopathic Autism
Spectrum Disorders Treated with Fluoxetine Two-year award - $109,703 Mirella
Dapretto, Ph.D.
University of California at Los Angeles
(Los Angeles, CA) Language & Prosody in Autism: Evidence from fMRI Two-year
award - $120,000 Michelle Dunn, Ph.D.
Albert Einstein College of Medicine
(Bronx, NY) Understanding Cortical Auditory Processing Abnormalities in Children
with Autism Two-year award - $119,912 Michelle Dunn, Ph.D.
Albert Einstein College of Medicine
(Bronx, NY) Mapping Lexical Organization in Children with Autism Two-year award
- $119,912 Nicole Gage, Ph.D.
University of California at Irvine
(Irvine, CA) MEG Investigations of Cortical Auditory Processing in Children with
Autism Two-year award - $109,788 H. Hill Goldsmith, Ph.D.
University of Wisconsin at Madison
(Madison, WI) A Birth Register-based Twin Study of Autism Spectrum Disorders
Two-year award - $118,910 Eli Hatchwell, Ph.D.
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory (Cold
Spring Harbor, NY) Genomic Copy Number Variation in Autism One-year award -
$60,000 Karl Herrup, Ph.D.
Case Western Reserve University
(Cleveland, OH) The Engrailed-2 Mutant as a Model of the Neuropathology of
Autism Two-year award - $120,000 Laura Hewitson, Ph.D.
University of Pittsburgh (Pittsburgh, PA)
Autism in Primates: Genetics vs Environment Two-year award - $118,825 Jana
Iverson, Ph.D.
University of Missouri at Columbia
(Columbia, MO) Early
Identification of Autism: A Prospective Study
Two-year award - $119,861
Russell Margolis, M.D.
Johns Hopkins School of Medicine
(Baltimore, MD) Genetic Mutations Associated with Autism in Unexplored Regions
of FOXP2 One-year award - $56,063 James Millonig, Ph.D.
University of Medicine & Dentistry of New
Jersey/Robert Wood Johnson Medical School (Piscataway, NJ) Studying Mouse
Cerebellar Development as a Tool to Identify Autism Susceptibility Genes
Two-year award - $120,000 Sherie Novotny, M.D.
Mt. Sinai School of Medicine (New York,
NY) Galantamine vs Placebo in Childhood & Adolescent Autism Two-year award -
$118,526 Payam Rezaie, Ph.D.
The Open University (Milton Keynes,
England) Assessment of the Glial Response Within the Cerebral Cortex in Autism
Two-year award - $119,973 Timothy Roberts, Ph.D.
University of Toronto (Toronto, Ontario)
MEG Correlates of Linguistic Processing at and Below the Word Level in Autism
Two-year award - $119,918 Peter Scheiffele, Ph.D.
Columbia University (New York, NY)
Frequency & Functional Characterization of Neuroligin Mutations Two-year award -
$119,998 Stephen Sheinkopf, Ph.D.
Brown Medical School (Providence, RI)
Vagal Tone & Social Behaviors in Children with Autistic Disorder Two-year award
- $116,952 Elise Temple, Ph.D.
Cornell University (Ithaca, NY) Neural
Mechanisms Underlying Theory of Mind: fMRI Studies of Normally Developing and
Autistic Children Two-year award - $112,916 Poul Thorsen, M.D., Ph.D.
NANEA at Department of Epidemiology and
Social Medicine/Aarhus University (Denmark) Exposure to Pharmaceuticals in
Pregnancy & Development of Autistic Disorder Two-year award - $118,454 Jochen
Triesch, Ph.D.
University of California at San Diego (La
Jolla, CA) The MESA Project: Modeling the Emergence of Shared Attention Two-year
award - $120,000 Michael Ullman, Ph.D.
Georgetown University (Washington, DC)
Neurocognitive Correlates of Language in Autism Two-year award - $118,575 John
Welsh, Ph.D.
Oregon Health & Science University
(Portland, OR) Inferior Olive &
Autism: Electrical Synapses, Neuronal Synchrony
& Cognition Two-year award - $101,639 Justin Williams, M.B.B.S., MSc University
of Aberdeen (Aberdeen,
England) Functional Neuroimaging Studies of
Action, Facial and Object-directed Imitation Two-year award - $119,977 Peter
Zandi, Ph.D.
Johns Hopkins School of Public Health
(Baltimore, MD) Maternal-fetal Incompatibility and Autism Risk One-year award -
$59,998 Xiaoxi Zhuang, Ph.D.
University of Chicago (Chicago, IL)
Behavioral Effects of Hyper- and Hypo-Serotonergic Function in Transgenic Mouse
Models Two-year award - $120,000 Lonnie Zwaigenbaum, M.D.
McMaster University (Hamilton, Ontario)
Investigating the Emergence of Familial Traits in Autism Two-year award -
$120,000 Mentor-Based Fellowships & Autism Training Programs - $991,000
Pre-Doctoral Fellowships Centre for Molecular Medicine & Therapeutics,
Vancouver, British Columbia
Mentor: Elizabeth Simpson, Ph.D.
Fellow: K.Y. Bibiana Wong Mouse Models
of Autism: Behavior and
Genetics Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN
Mentor: James Sutcliffe, Ph.D.
Fellow: Jacob McCauley Genetic Analysis
of Serotonergic and
GABA-ergic Genes in Autism University of
Massachusetts, Boston, MA Mentor: Alice Carter, Ph.D.
Fellow: Chantal Jennifer Kuhn The Impact
of Parental Autism-related
Cognitions on Interventions Johns Hopkins
School of Public Health,
Baltimore, MD Mentor: Craig Newschaffer, Ph.D.
Fellow: Keely Cheslack-Postava
Epidemiology of Autism Spectrum
Disorders Universidad Miguel Hernandez, San
Juan de Alicante (Spain)
Mentor: Jorge J. Prieto, M.D., Ph.D.
Fellow: Edith Lopez Hurtado
Immuncytochemical and Morphometrical
Analysis of Double Bouquet Cells Microcircuitry
in the Cerebral Cortex of
Autistic Patients Princeton University,
Princeton, NJ Mentor: Samuel
Wang, Ph.D.
Fellow: Megan Sullivan Multiphoton
Investigation of Sensory Encoding in the Mammalian Cerebellum Post-Doctoral
Fellowships Cambridge
University, Cambridge (England) Mentor: Simon
Baron-Cohen, Ph.D.
Fellow: Christopher D. Ashwin, Ph.D.
Social Emotional Processing University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI
Mentor: Jeffrey Hutsler, Ph.D.
Fellow: Hong Zhang, Ph.D.
Quantitative Neuroanatomical Training: New
Methods to Reveal Structural Changes in the Cortex of Individuals with Autism
The Institute of Psychiatry at Kings College, London (England) Mentor:
Francesca Happe, Ph.D.
Fellow: Aparna Nadig, Ph.D.
A Language Processing View of Pragmatic
Impairments in Autism Spectrum Disorders University of Medicine & Dentistry of
New Jersey/Robert Wood
Johnson Medical School, Piscataway, NJ Mentor:
Emanuel DiCicco-Bloom, M.D.
Fellow: Kristina Sennvik, Ph.D.
Neurodevelopmental Origins of Autism Brain
Abnormalities Yale
University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT
Mentor: Paul Bloom, Ph.D.
Fellow: Melissa Allen Preissler, Ph.D.
Symbolic Understanding in Children with
Autism Columbia University -
College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, NY
Mentor: Carol Mason,
Ph.D.
Fellow: Phillip Buttery, Ph.D.
Regulation of the Purkinje Cell, Dendritic
Growth, Spine Formation and Synaptogenesis Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN
Mentor: Wendy Stone, Ph.D.
Fellow: Robin Page, Ph.D.
Developing a Downward Extension of the
STAT Autism Training Programs NAAR is collaborating with the Canadian Institute
of Neurosciences, Mental Health and Addiction to co-sponsor a pair of six-year,
interdisciplinary autism training programs, known as the Training Programs in
Autism
Research. NAAR will invest approximately
$200,000 annually for six years
as a co-sponsor of this unique program - the
first of its kind in Canada to focus on autism.
More than 1,500 families are planning to
bring legal action against manufacturers of the MMR vaccine, despite the High
Court ruling last week that ordered two mothers to give their children the jab.
A class action against GlaxoSmithKline, the largest manufacturer of the vaccine,
Aventis Pasteur and Merck and Co. is being prepared by solicitors acting for
parents who believe their children were harmed by the immunisation.
The prospects for civil action appear not
to have been dented by the controversial High Court ruling last Friday, which
resulted in two mothers being ordered to let their girls have the MMR jab. Their
fathers want them to have the immunisation.
One of the mothers said another freedom
had been eroded after Mr Justice Sumner decided to go against her and another
mothers wishes. In a statement released yesterday, the mother said: Its
outrageous that in a free society a judge could make such a decision.
This ruling makes it possible for
officials to take my child and inject her with MMR jabs against my beliefs and
my will - against the will of her mother, who lives with her, cares for her and
looks after her. And for what? During the High Court hearing, Mr Justice
Sumner said he was aware that the civil trial was pending next April, and added
that his ruling should not be seen as a general approval of immunisation: It
does not mean that, at another hearing, a different decision might not be
reached. The parents, many of them supported by legal aid, claim that, before
their children were vaccinated, they were developing normally, but after the
injections suffered health problems, including autism and bowel disorders.
* * *
LITERATURE
Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time:
The Remains of the Dog Math and Physics? A Cinch. People? Incomprehensible. By
Michiko Kakutani
This new book (fiction) has a 15-year old with
Aspergers/autism as the narrator.
Christophers book seemingly has a nice
tidy ending, as he would have wished -- horrified as he is of indeterminacy. But
this tidiness is an illusion, as the gulf between Christopher and his parents,
between Christopher and the rest of us, remains immense and mysterious. And that
gulf is ultimately the source of this novels haunting impact. Christopher Boone
is an unsolved mystery -- but he is certainly one of the strangest and most
convincing characters in recent fiction.
Christophers mind is logical and literal
in the extreme; early on he suggests that metaphor is a form of lying, pointing
out that very few people actually have skeletons in their closets or apples in
their eyes. When I try and make a picture of the phrase in my head it just
confuses me because imagining an apple in someones eye doesnt have anything to
do with liking someone a lot and it makes you forget what the person was talking
about. Christophers inability to tell lies is one of the many reasons he has
difficulty engaging in, or understanding, normal social intercourse. And his
distaste for falsehood is one reason he doesnt like novels, except for murder
mysteries, which are essentially puzzles, Sherlock Holmes being his literary
hero -- though he has problems with Arthur Conan Doyle, Holmess creator, who
became involved with spiritualism later in life. Christophers mind is purely
scientific.
Fifteen-year-old Christopher Boone of
Swindon, England, seems, at first glance, an unpromising narrator for a novel --
a curious hybrid of reliable and unreliable. By his own admission he doesnt
like fiction. He is incapable of lying, of understanding metaphor or jokes. Hes
also incapable of reading any but the most basic of human facial expressions.
Usually people look at you when theyre talking to you. I know that theyre
working out what Im thinking, but I cant tell what theyre thinking. It is
like being in a room with a one-way mirror in a spy film. His own range of
emotional response is so limited he makes the repressed butler in Kazuo
Ishiguros Remains of the Day -- a novel that this one resembles in its
elegant economy of means -- seem like Zorba the Greek.
Haddon manages to bring us deep inside
Christophers mind and situates us comfortably within his limited, severely
logical point of view, to the extent that we begin to question the common sense
and the erratic emotionalism of the normal citizens who surround him, as well as
our own intuitions and habits of perception.
If all this sounds somewhat grim and
clinical, its not. Christophers skewed perspective and fierce logic make him a
superb straight man, if not necessarily a stellar detective. In the course of
interrogating one of his neighbors, while waiting impatiently for her to cut the
chitchat, he
observes: Mrs. Alexander was doing what is
called chatting, where people say things to each other which arent questions
and answers and arent connected. . . . I tried to do chatting by saying, My
age is 15 years and 3 months and 3 days. His inability to interpret basic
social cues results in great moments of deadpan comedy, with strangers as well
as with his patient, long-suffering father.
Midway through the book, Christophers
quest for the dogs murderer becomes a search for his mother, who his father has
told him is dead. His solo journey from Swindon to London is, for him, a
terrifying leap into the unknown, as suspenseful and harrowing as anything in
Conan Doyle. He literally sees everything around him and is unable to edit the
onslaught of sensory data in a new environment. And he is afraid of strangers
and ill equipped to ask for their help.
One of the subtle ironies of the book,
given the evolution of the murder mystery detective toward the tough guys of
Hammett and Chandler, is that young Christopher is ultimately far more
hard-boiled than any gumshoe in previous detective fiction; unlike Sam Spade or
Nick Charles, he has no sentimental streak, no underground reservoir of
emotional identification with other human beings -- although he is fond of dogs.
The books jacket copy identifies him as
an autistic savant, but Christopher tells us all we need to know about his
condition without reference to medical terminology -- just as well, since the
term autism encompasses a variety of symptoms and behavioral problems that are
still baffling behavioral scientists. The American Psychiatric Association
definition includes problems with social interaction, verbal and nonverbal
communication and a restrictive repertoire of activities and interests. The
problems of autism are related to how the brain processes, organizes and
retrieves information; Christopher compares his own brain to a computer that is
easily overloaded by multitasking. He has a photographic memory and is capable
of working out complicated factoring problems in his head but is so overwhelmed
by unfamiliar visual or verbal stimuli that sometimes he shuts down, holding his
hands over his eyes or his ears while he groans or screams. He abhors physical
contact, new environments and the colors yellow and brown.
The difference between literature and its
imitations might be defined in any number of ways, but lets be reckless, even
elitist, and propose that a literary novel requires new reading skills and
teaches them within its pages, while a conventional novel -- whether it is about
lawyers or professors or smart single girls -- depends on our ingrained habits
of reading and perception, and ultimately confirms them as adequate to our
understanding of the world around us. Mark Haddons stark, funny and original
first novel, The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, is presented
as a detective story. But it eschews most of the furnishings of high-literary
enterprise as well as the conventions of genre, disorienting and reorienting the
reader to devastating effect.
When Christopher discovers his neighbors
poodle dead, skewered on a pitchfork, he sets out to solve the mystery and to
write a true account of his detective work. In so doing he inadvertently
stumbles upon the messy, illogical, emotionally complicated secrets of his
parents and their neighbors. And even as he is finally forced to come to some
limited accommodation of this knowledge, he makes a kind of plausible case for
his own, ostensibly crippled worldview. Perhaps the greatest mystery here is
whether Christopher is capable of change -- a question that goes to the heart of
certain deeply held convictions about character.
* * *
LETTER
A Simple Test for the Need to Vaccinate
It seems quite simple, but I have found in
my practice not many parents are aware they can request a titer to be drawn on
their children to determine if immunity is present. This is a blood test. If
immunity is present, then there is no need to receive the vaccination.
DISCLAIMER: All
information, data, and material contained, presented, or provided here is for
general information purposes only and is not to be construed as reflecting the
knowledge or opinions of the publisher, and is not to be construed or intended
as providing medical or legal advice. The decision whether or not to vaccinate
is an important and complex issue and should be made by you, and you alone, in
consultation with your health care provider.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"