June 13, 2003
LONDON (AP) -- A High Court judge on Friday ordered two
girls aged 4 and 10 to be given the measle-mumps-rubella (MMR)
vaccine against their mothers' wishes.
The girls' fathers, who live separately from the youngsters
and their mothers, had argued in favor of the triple vaccine,
currently required in more than 90 countries.
Some British parents have refused to give their children
the combined vaccination following a 1998 British study --
since contested -- which concluded that the vaccine could be
linked to autism, a severe neurological disorder usually
diagnosed around the age of 2, the same age that the vaccine
is given.
Justice Christopher Sumner Friday said the court "has to
decide whether immunization is in (the girls') interests,
whether the mothers' opposition should prevail, and whether an
order should be made.
"Recognizing the anxieties of the mothers and that an
adverse decision will be upsetting, the children's best
interests are served by receiving a program of immunizations
and an order should be made," he said.
The judge said the benefits of the triple inoculation
outweigh any risks posed by the treatment.
But he stressed that his ruling should not be seen as a
general approval of giving the MMR vaccination to all
children.
"I accept a parent's right to choose whether they accept
medical advice to have immunization for their children or
not," he said.
The girls cannot be identified because they are under age,
and they were referred to in court proceedings by the initials
C and F.
Many British parents' fears appear to be the result of a
surge of publicity about one doctor's concerns about the
safety of the triple inoculation.
Since the 1998 study, several authoritative groups of
international scientists have examined the evidence --
including a panel that reviewed five decades of research on
the vaccine's side effects -- and concluded there is no
evidence of a connection.
However, many parents remain unconvinced and health
authorities fear a measles comeback.
Copyright 2003 The Associated Press. All rights
reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast,
rewritten, or redistributed.