20 Cases of Disease Related to Smallpox Found in the U.S.
By LAWRENCE K. ALTMAN and JODI WILGOREN
Monkeypox, a viral disease related to smallpox but less infectious and less
deadly, has been detected for the first time in the Americas with at least 20
cases reported in three Midwestern states, the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention said yesterday.
Wisconsin reported the vast majority, 18; Illinois and Indiana had one each.
The patients ranged in age from 4 to 48 and became ill between May 15 and June
3. All had had direct or close contact with ill prairie dogs, which have become
common household pets and which might have caught monkeypox from another
species, possibly Gambian giant pouched rats, which are imported as pets from
West or Central Africa, where the disease has long occurred. Monkeypox in Africa
is carried mainly by squirrels, but named after monkeys because it often kills
them.
Several patients in the American outbreak work for veterinarians or pet
stores that sold prairie dogs and Gambian rats. No patients have died and four
have been hospitalized. Laboratory tests performed at the disease centers in
Atlanta yesterday confirmed that the patients had been infected with the
monkeypox virus, which belongs to the same Orthopox family that includes the
virus that causes smallpox.
The monkeypox patients typically fell ill with signs and symptoms like fever,
headaches, dry cough, swollen lymph nodes, chills and drenching sweats,
Wisconsin health officials said. One to 10 days later, the patients developed
rashes consisting of blisterlike pimples that filled with pus, broke open and
later produced scabs. The rash often erupted in different stages, or crops, as
it appeared on the head, trunk and arms and legs. Monkeypox lesions can scar the
skin like smallpox or chickenpox.
Most monkeypox patients became ill 4 to 12 days after exposure to a sick
animal, but the incubation period may have been as long as 20 days.
The federal disease centers issued a health alert about monkeypox on Saturday
night in part out of its concern that doctors who had treated the cases had
initially mistaken some for smallpox and chickenpox, said Dr. Stephen M.
Ostroff, an epidemiologist at the agency.
Another concern was quickly alerting the public because the cases occurred so
recently and because more people could be infected from diseased animals, which
were sold in recent days.
By quickly identifying the animals that can be infected with monkeypox,
health officials hope to eliminate them before the disease becomes endemic in
this country and in the Americas, Dr. Ostroff said. For this and other reasons,
the disease centers advised people not to release into the wild live animals
suspected of being infected with monkeypox.
Smallpox vaccination can protect against monkeypox, but at least one patient
in the current outbreak in this country had been vaccinated for smallpox before
routine vaccination was discontinued in 1972.
The disease agency has not recommended a ban on sales of prairie dogs and
Gambian rats because the agency is still "in an information-gathering stage,"
Dr. Ostroff said.
But two states, Illinois and Wisconsin, have acted to end the sale and
distribution of prairie dogs and Gambian rats.
On Friday afternoon, Wisconsin officials issued a quarantine prohibiting
importation, sale and movement of prairie dogs received after April 1 and any
nonhuman mammals that come in contact with them. On Saturday night, Gov. Rod R.
Blagojevich of Illinois signed an executive order prohibiting sales, import or
even public display of these animals.
The Centers for Disease Control is asking physicians, veterinarians and
members of the public to report to their local health departments any rash that
develops in people within 21 days after they are exposed to prairie dogs,
Gambian rats or other animals.
The agency also advised hospital workers caring for suspected monkeypox
patients to follow standard infection control measures, including the gloves,
gowns and N-95 masks that have been used to protect against SARS. The agency
also advised veterinarians to take the same precautions in caring for sick
prairie dogs, Gambian rats, other rodents and rabbits.
Monkeypox has long been known to cause sporadic infections in the jungles of
West and Central Africa. A sputtering outbreak of monkeypox has been occurring
in recent years in Congo.
Up to 10 percent of monkeypox cases have been fatal in West Africa, according
to different studies; before smallpox was eradicated, its death rate was about
30 percent.
Studies have shown that outbreaks of monkeypox tend to die out in humans as
the virus passes through successive waves, or generations, of cases. This
contrasts with smallpox, which continues to spread for centuries until the
person-to-person chain of transmission is broken.
The sudden appearance of monkeypox in the United States is a surprise,
representing the latest in a series of emerging diseases to reach this country.
A prime example is the mosquito-borne West Nile fever, which has spread through
the country since it first entered the Americas in 1999.
Precisely how monkeypox reached the United States is unknown. Dr. Ostroff
said that the disease agency was investigating possibilities that included the
arrival of an infected person or animal from West Africa.
Dr. Kurt Reed, an infectious-disease pathologist who runs the microbiology
laboratory and the clinical research center at the Marshfield Clinic in central
Wisconsin, said his laboratory had detected the virus in specimens from a
4-year-old girl who had been bitten on the finger by her new pet prairie dog in
mid-May.
The girl's parents, who also had contact with the prairie dog, later
developed the disease, though the 38-year-old father, who had been vaccinated
against smallpox as a child, had a milder case. The monkeypox virus was also
detected in a lymph node from the prairie dog, which died a few days later.
The girl went to the clinic with a lesion on her finger, Dr. Reed said, and
bacterial cultures quickly ruled out tularemia and the plague. Biopsies of
lesions taken from the girl's mother showed a poxlike virus. Cultures from the
mother's virus and from the prairie dog matched and suggested an ailment from
the Orthopox family, Dr. Reed said.
"Right then we knew we had something interesting," he said. "We do lots and
lots of virus cultures. This was very unusual. There's nothing really in the
literature about prairie dogs having pox viruses."
When the clinic contacted the state health department, the doctors were told
of similar cases in the Milwaukee area and learned that the prairie dogs may
have been housed with Gambian rats through an exotic pet dealer in suburban
Chicago. "That really raised the suspicion that this was an old-world virus that
had made its way into the United States," Dr. Reed said.
The disease agency said that the prairie dogs were sold by a Milwaukee animal
distributor in May to two pet shops in the Milwaukee area and during a pet "swap
meet" in northern Wisconsin. The Milwaukee animal distributor obtained prairie
dogs and a Gambian giant rat, which was ill at the time, from a northern
Illinois animal distributor. Investigations are under way to trace the source of
the animals and to find where they went, Centers for Disease Control officials
said.
Preliminary information suggests that animals from this distributor may have
been sold in several other states, which the agency did not name.
Prairie dogs and Gambian rats are part of a wide array of exotic animals
feeding a growing and diversifying niche pet market, though some animal rights
advocates oppose their domestication.
Prairie dogs, plant-eating members of the squirrel family, are believed to
have a sophisticated communication system through smell and touch, and they are
known to burrow complex underground tunnel systems.
The rats, which grow to the size of small cats, eat pet food mixes as well as
fruits, vegetables and cooked meats.
"They are intelligent, social and can be very gentle if handled from an early
age," one enthusiast, Jazmyn Concolor, posted on the Web site www.altpet.net,
adding that one rat sleeps with a stuffed toy lion. "They are not pets for
everyone, requiring patience and understanding of their habits."
The disease centers urged people to avoid contact with prairie dogs and
Gambian rats that have missing patches of fur, rashes or discharges from their
eyes or nose, all signs of the illness. The agency also urged people to wash
their hands with soap and water after contact with any animal and to warn
doctors and hospitals in advance in seeking medical care if they thought they
might be infected.
Pet owners were strongly advised to call veterinarians to euthanize any
animals suspected of having monkeypox, but only after warning the veterinarians
so they can take precautions.
Infected people who are being treated outside hospitals should be isolated
and should not have guests until scabs from any lesions fall off. If no rash
develops, isolation is recommended until 10 days after the onset of symptoms.
Patients and their household members are advised to use vinyl or latex gloves
to handle scabs and to dispose of them in double plastic garbage bags. The bags
should be secured in garbage cans, away from potential contact with animals.
Infected people are advised to sleep alone and to wear surgical masks to
reduce risk of transmitting the virus.
Because the monkeypox virus can persist on surfaces and objects, pet owners
are advised to clean animal cages and bedding, and to use gloves in doing so.
The disease agency issued no specific treatment recommendations, but
scientists are testing an antiviral drug, cidofovir, for its efficacy.
DISCLAIMER: All
information, data, and material contained, presented, or provided here is for
general information purposes only and is not to be construed as reflecting the
knowledge or opinions of the publisher, and is not to be construed or intended
as providing medical or legal advice. The decision whether or not to vaccinate
is an important and complex issue and should be made by you, and you alone, in
consultation with your health care provider.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"