|

Sparks fly over
UK "health contracts" proposal
By Corinne Amoo
Last Updated: 2003-06-03
12:42:58 -0400 (Reuters Health)
LONDON (Reuters) - Chain
smokers and the overweight may be asked to sign contracts promising
to lead healthier lives in return for medical treatment under plans
being considered by the British government.
The contracts would set
out patients' responsibilities and offer them help to cut down or
quit smoking, lose weight, get more exercise or eat a more
nutritious diet.
Patients would receive
treatment in return for following the doctors' advice, according to
the concept. Those who fell by the wayside would not actually be
turned away -- but the mere idea has prompted predictions of the
demise of Britain's free National Health Service (NHS).
"The NHS was founded on
the principle that you do not discriminate on people on the basis of
lifestyle," said a spokeswoman for the Freedom Organisation for the
Right to Enjoy Smoking Tobacco.
"If people are forced to
give up smoking or lose weight before they see a doctor it will
signal the death of the NHS."
Even doctors themselves
are unenthusiastic.
"This idea amounts to a
bureaucratic nightmare," said Dr. John Chisholm, chairman of the
British Medical Association's General Practitioners Committee.
"The proposals seem to
threaten the doctor-patient relationship and potentially even to
deny people the free care to which I believe they are entitled," he
added in a statement.
A Labour Party spokesman
denied any intention to withdraw treatment.
"The consultation
document covers the shared rights and responsibilities between the
NHS and patients. It is not about restricting treatment or making
treatment conditional," he said.
The agreement would take
the form of a joint statement of "mutual good intent," he added.
The proposals, which
could become part of Labour's manifesto at the next general election
if ratified at the annual party conference, are aimed at easing the
pressures put on the NHS by avoidable, lifestyle-related diseases.
Copyright 2002 Reuters.
|