Story last updated at
12:53 a.m. Sunday, June 1, 2003
India's dramatic rise in new polio cases threatens global eradication
program By BETH DUFF-BROWN Associated Press Writer
Two Muslim women come back after administering polio
vaccines to their children at the Tiljala slum area in Calcutta,
India, April 24. Loss of faith, government fatigue and the myth
among Muslims that the polio vaccine could cause infertility or
impotence in their children led to a dramatic, six-fold increase in
polio cases in India last year. (AP photo)
CALCUTTA, India (AP) Rani Begum lost her faith, somewhere
in the wretched slums sandwiched between fetid sewage canals on the eastern
outskirts of Calcutta.
Despite her poverty, Begum obeyed the constant reminders by local health
workers to take her two little girls to the clinic for oral polio vaccine.
But her youngest, 2-year-old Simran, now sits idly on their woven bamboo
mattress, her left leg limp since she contracted the crippling disease last
year.
³I have no faith in these people anymore. Despite the polio drops, my child
was hit with it,² says Begum.
Simran Khatun, 2, her left leg affected by polio, and
her mother Rani Begum sit in a slum in Calcutta, India, April 24.
(AP photo)
Such feelings are worrisome for the international campaign to wipe out polio,
which would make it the second disease to be eradicated worldwide, after
smallpox.
India saw a dramatic, sixfold increase in polio cases last year, indicating a
falloff in children getting vaccine. Health workers blame distrust in the
government, official disgruntlement over the program¹s cost and rumors among
Muslims that the vaccine can cause infertility.
Health workers don¹t know why Simran contracted polio, but say it¹s likely
her mother didn¹t follow the correct dosage or the vaccine was not potent from
improper refrigeration or mishandling.
India reported 1,556 new cases of polio last year, or 84 percent of all cases
worldwide, the World Health Organization says.
A group of women bathe, wash and fetch drinking water
at the same source at the Tiljala slum area in Calcutta, India,
April 24, 2003. Loss of faith, government fatigue and the myth among
Muslims that the polio vaccine could cause infertility or impotence
in their children led to a dramatic, six-fold increase in polio
cases in India last year. (AP Photo/Bikas Das)
That¹s solid progress from the 1980s, when India had as many as 200,000 new
cases a year. But this South Asian nation of a billion people is one of the
world¹s last reservoirs of the polio virus, and each new case increases the
chance of its spreading elsewhere.
³We are so close, we cannot allow all our success to go to waste,² said Dr.
Anubha Ghose, a pediatrician who herself contracted polio as a child, before
there was a vaccine. ³This last push is the most difficult, but we have no
option but to move forward.²
Ghose, director of health for the humanitarian group CARE India, said the
government has grown weary of the effort to vaccinate all of India¹s children
against polio, having spent $300 million on the program since 1996. Officials
wonder if the money might be better spent on diseases that kill more children,
such as malaria and cholera.
³The bureaucrats who are allocating the money, they cannot say at the end of
the day that they saved so many children,² she said. ³We can only say to them:
It¹s our responsibility to the world.²
The federal health minister, Sushma Swaraj, recently proclaimed that India
would be free of new polio cases next year despite the upturn. She blamed the
increase in cases partly on ³fictitious reporting² in previous years by some
field workers competing for lower figures.
Polio typically strikes before age 5. It can cripple the spinal cord, causing
paralysis and, in some cases, death. It is transmitted through food or water
contaminated by the fecal matter of an infected person.
Though polio has been suppressed in many parts of the world the last case
in the Western Hemisphere was more than a decade ago children worldwide will
be at risk until the last case is wiped out.
³If you don¹t eradicate it everywhere, it can come back and then you have to
start all over again,² said Dr. Jay Wenger, WHO project manager for the National
Polio Surveillance Project in India.
On May 13, WHO and its partners in the global eradication campaign announced
that they will cut back on immunization programs in many countries to
concentrate efforts in India and 12 other nations.
Carl Tinstman of the U.N. Children¹s Fund said health officials learned a
lesson during the past two years when they cut back efforts in India, thinking
the virus was well under control.
³It was a misjudgment,² Tinstman said.
When the worldwide effort began in 1988, with a goal of wiping out polio by
2005, there were 350,000 polio new cases in 125 countries. Last year, 1,866 new
cases were reported, and polio was considered endemic in only seven nations:
India, Nigeria, Niger, Egypt, Somalia, Afghanistan and Pakistan.
In India¹s West Bengal province, around Calcutta, there was only one new case
in all of 2001. Then last year, 48 cases were reported, and in the first four
months of this year 22 more cases occurred in the densely populated state, which
borders Bangladesh and Nepal, both polio-free nations.
³This should be sending off alarm bells,² Ghose said.
Such alarm doesn¹t filter down into the slums of Calcutta, where hunger and
disappointment drown out any calls for global responsibility.
Begum, whose husband is a rickshaw puller, says there is no way she¹ll get
the last of the four polio doses for her older daughter, 4-year-old Pinky.
³The more you give the drops, the greater the chance you¹ll get polio,² she
says.
Across the city, Mohammed Taher, 14, limps through the sprawling slums around
the Park Circus railroad station, along the Ganges River. He doesn¹t go to
school and is on his way to his job in a shoe factory.
Taher, whose left leg is badly twisted outward, believes he contracted polio
when he was inoculated for measles as a toddler. ³I don¹t know anything about
these polio drops,² he says with a shrug. ³Anyway, it¹s god¹s will.²
His neighbors, brothers Dawood and Mustaq Hussein, 16 and 14, also believe it
was their fate to contract polio. But they feel it¹s their duty to prevent it in
others.
³We¹ve accepted it and we could care less,² says Mustaq. ³We tell the mothers
that they must get the drops or their children will end up like us.²
Many of the new cases of polio have been among Muslims like Begum, Taher and
the Husseins. Some in India¹s largest minority fear the vaccine is part of a
government plot to limit the Muslim population in India, which is predominantly
Hindu.
³There¹s some distrust of the government in general because they don¹t get
much from the government in general,² said Wenger, the WHO official. ³And what
little they do get, they tend to be suspicious.²
Prabhakar Chatterjee, director of health services for West Bengal, said such
tales are hard to quell.
He went house to house on the last national polio immunization day, April 6,
encouraging parents to give their youngsters the polio drops. One Muslim couple
with five daughters and one son resisted.
³I finally convinced them to agree to the five girls,² Chatterjee said. ³But
not the son. They worried the family name would die out if the boy was sterile.²
DISCLAIMER: All
information, data, and material contained, presented, or provided here is for
general information purposes only and is not to be construed as reflecting the
knowledge or opinions of the publisher, and is not to be construed or intended
as providing medical or legal advice. The decision whether or not to vaccinate
is an important and complex issue and should be made by you, and you alone, in
consultation with your health care provider.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"