Nicholas Carson, 16, has an
unusual contraption floating above his head.
It
is a foot-long, upside-down ice-cream cone
anchored by ropes to each of his ears and to a
point on his forehead. In the tip of this cone is
where Nicholas nestles his roving,
three-dimensional imagination -- his mind's eye --
when he needs to concentrate to read words or tell
time.
The cone is not real. It exists in Nicholas's
robust imagination. But the condition that makes
it necessary is. Nicholas is dyslexic. And far
from seeing this as a tragic affliction that must
be overcome, he is certain that it is a gift, the
source of his future success.
"It has lots of advantages," he said from
Edmonton earlier this week. "I can visualize
things better. Building things is easier. I'm
hoping to become a millionaire."
Nicholas and his mother, Paddy Carson, who is
also dyslexic, are part of a growing new movement
that is redefining dyslexia. Rather than thinking
of it as a learning disability, a disease, a
malfunction of the brain, the fruit of a stubborn,
lazy or stupid child, or even as the figment of a
parent's imagination, people who have dyslexia --
and researchers who study it -- are beginning to
see it as a blessing that opens up new worlds.
And a muscular batch of neurological research
is adding to the movement. Among them is the study
published this week in Neurology, the scientific
journal of the American Academy of Neurology. It
showed that a specially designed course could
improve a dyslexic's ability to read after only
three weeks.
Other examinations of the brains of dyslexics
and non-dyslexics are showing subtle structural
differences between the two in both the cerebral
cortex and the thalamus. (The differences appear
to be genetic.) For one thing, the hemispheres of
dyslexics' brains are more symmetrical than those
of people who are not dyslexic. That likely makes
it tougher for dyslexics to learn to read and
write, but it is perfect for other complex brain
functions involving pictures and three dimensions.
Gordon Sherman, one of the most eminent North
American researchers on dyslexia, says society can
benefit from the condition -- if educators learn
to help dyslexics harness their abilities.
Dr. Sherman, who has a PhD in developmental
psychobiology, says that the dyslexic mind is
evidence of evolution's ancient demand for
diversity. Just as the human immune system differs
among individuals -- some are susceptible to HIV,
for example, while others are unaffected -- the
human brain has evolved to ensure that different
abilities exist in various people. It's a
mechanism designed to ensure the survival of the
species.
"We need diversity. Dyslexia may be an
excellent example of brain diversity," says Dr.
Sherman.
Simply put, dyslexics do not appear to sort
through information in a linear, sequential way.
Instead of doing one thing and then another, they
do a variety of things at the same time, very
quickly. Their technique is almost a blueprint for
being a visionary or a strategist or, in different
eras, a seeker of safe places in the jungle.
Many excel at spatial perception. Dr. Sherman
was recently involved in a study comparing the
spatial abilities of dyslexics and non-dyslexics
that found the former were much faster at a key
skill: identifying "impossible figures," or forms
that could not logically be put together (such as
optical illusions or the images M.C. Escher
painted). Dyslexics could understand instantly
that these figures were flawed.
Over history, many people now understood to be
dyslexics have made bold advances in science, art,
music, politics and sports. Among them are Albert
Einstein, Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo,
Alexander Graham Bell and Winston Churchill.
"We could produce a high percentage of
individuals who are really contributing to society
in quite special ways," says Dr. Sherman.
Although dyslexics shouldn't rule out any line
of work because of their condition, their
heightened sense of spatial perception may lead
them to gravitate toward composing and performing
music, athletics, carpentry, architecture, art,
abstract math or surgery.
Nicholas, for instance, used to be what his
mother calls a "Lego-maniac." She remembers when
he was about 8 and got a set designed to build a
huge castle. He took one look at the picture and
knew instantly, in three dimensions, where the
pieces went.
Today, he's excellent at playing underwater
hockey (a favourite sport) and three-dimensional
war-strategy games.
It's been hard for him to accept that his brain
structure is a blessing. He didn't read until he
was 12, and school can still be a struggle. He
thinks in pictures, and school is run by what he
calls "word-thinkers."
He's in summer school now and is fighting with
a Grade 10 English course that is heavy on essays,
stories and poems.
"I find the words just get in the way," he
says. "I don't really understand in words. I
understand in pictures."
The breakthrough for Nicholas came when his
mother read The Gift of Dyslexia: Why Some of
the Smartest People Can't Read and How They Can
Learn by Ronald Davis with Eldon Braun. Mr.
Davis, a dyslexic who is poised to publish a
follow-up title next month, came up with a way to
teach some dyslexics to read.
Wayne Aadelstone-Hassel, who teaches the Davis
program privately in Vancouver, explains that the
system involves finding a place for the child's
restless imagination to rest (like Nicholas's
ice-cream cone).
The key is understanding that dyslexics have a
three-dimensional imagination that is mobile.
For example, if a dyslexic thinks about
designing a building, it's not a question of
visualizing a flat drawing. Instead, the dyslexic
instantly sees a 3-D building, spins it around and
roams around inside it. When the dyslexic tries to
apply that type of brain to flat objects, it's
trouble.
The letter "b," for instance, is only a b if
you look at it straight on and consider it to be
two-dimensional. Viewed from behind, it's a d.
From above, it's a p, and below, a q. A dyslexic
sees all of these at the same time.
Mr. Aadelstone-Hassel remembers teaching a
10-year-old how to find a place to rest his
imagination while he looked at a book. The child
couldn't read yet, but was shocked when he looked
at the letters on the page.
The teacher asked what was different.
" 'Before this, these letters used to climb up
the steps, go down a slide and jump into a
swimming pool,' " Mr. Aadelstone-Hassel recalls
the boy saying. The child thought the letters did
that for everybody and didn't realize some people
saw them as motionless.
Now, Mr. Aadelstone-Hassel teaches dyslexics to
park that mind's eye when they need to. That gives
them the choice of working flat or round, as it
were, or of moving freely between the two as
needed.
He started helping dyslexics learn to read
after dealing unsuccessfully with so many of them
during his career as a teacher at the Vancouver
Waldorf School.
"I tried all the traditional ways of dealing
with it and I despaired," he says.
Once he learned about the Davis system, he
retired from teaching and now works with dyslexics
full-time. He, too, has come to see dyslexia as
something to cherish.
People with the condition tend to be highly
creative, imaginative, athletic and artistic, he
says. They think so fast that they often don't
know how they arrive at an answer. They are
excellent at solving problems, including being
able to visualize the finished product when they
see only the pieces.
On the other hand, they often have terrible
trouble following directions and have a low
threshold for confusion.
"They have a 360-degree consciousness and they
can move around in it," he says. "It's simply a
different way of knowing the world."
Unfortunately for the current generation of
dyslexics, at this juncture in human history,
society puts a premium on linear thinking. That's
being reinforced by trends in education such as
the stampede to standardized testing and cuts to
music and arts programs. Dr. Sherman says this
emphasis may be short-sighted.
"We certainly are egotistic enough to think we
know exactly what it takes to survive in the
future," he says. "We see the world through a very
narrow lens. In a sense, dyslexia teaches us how
wrong it could be."
In other words, over time, as society evolves,
it may prize the spatial learning abilities of
dyslexics over those who need words to learn.
To Nicholas, the educational system is stupid
and arrogant, a "conspiracy against dyslexia" that
he simply has to survive to get on with the
exciting part of his life.
Dr. Sherman says the irony is that while
dyslexia could be seen as a positive, the
inadequate teaching methods for dyslexics in
schools can turn them into disabled learners. They
lose confidence in themselves when none of the
teaching methods work. Two studies -- one from
Sweden and another from Texas -- have shown a very
high percentage of reading disabilities among
people in jail.
Ms. Carson, who found out as an adult that she
was dyslexic, says she was shocked and angry at
first. Then, she says, she began to take the gift,
use it and enjoy it.
What would she do if someone came up with a
cure that would eliminate her dyslexia?
"I'd refuse," she says, replying instantly.
"Without the Einsteins and the Michelangelos, life
would not be anywhere near as rich."
Alanna Mitchell is a senior features writer
at The Globe and Mail.
What to look for
Experts don't know what percentage of the
population has dyslexia, but estimates start at 12
per cent. The following symptoms are typical of
children between kindergarten and Grade 4:
May be slow to learn the connection between
letters and sounds
Has difficulty decoding single words (reading
single words in
isolation)
Has difficulty spelling phonetically
Makes consistent reading and spelling errors
such as:
Letter reversals -- "d" for "b"
(dog for bog)
Word reversals -- "tip" for "pit"
Inversions -- "m" for "w"
Transpositions -- "felt" for "left"
Substitutions -- "house" for "home"
May confuse small words
-- "at" for "to," "said" for "and," "does" for
"goes"
Relies on guessing and context
May have difficulty learning new vocabulary or
remembering facts
May transpose number sequences and confuse
arithmetic signs (+, -, x, /, =)
May be slow to learn new skills; relies heavily
on memorizing without understanding
May have difficulty planning, organizing and
managing time, materials and tasks
Often uses an awkward pencil grip (fist, thumb
hooked over fingers, etc.)
May have poor "fine motor"
co-ordination
For more information, visit
http://www.interdys.org
Source: The International Dyslexia Association