The researchers said there was no link
between the MMR vaccine and autism
|
The controversial MMR vaccine has not triggered an increase in
the number of children being diagnosed with autism, according to
experts.
Researchers at University College London say figures actually
show that the number of new cases has levelled off and may have
peaked 11 years ago.
They also said that the rise in new cases throughout the 1980s
and early 1990s may have been simply due to greater awareness of the
condition.
Nevertheless, the study found that parents were now more likely
to blame their children's autism on the MMR vaccine.
New cases
Professor Brent Taylor and colleagues at UCL identified 567
children born between 1979 and 1998 who were diagnosed with autism
in north-east London.
They found that the number of children being diagnosed with
autism peaked in 1992.
They reported that the number of new cases levelled off between
1992 and 1996, with between 45 and 50 children being diagnosed with
the condition.
This was equivalent to 2.6 cases for every 1,000 live births.
The researchers said that if autism was caused by the MMR vaccine
then figures would have jumped sharply throughout the early 1990s.
The MMR vaccine was introduced in Britain in 1988.
But writing in the journal Archives of Disease of Childhood, the
researchers said: "The appearance of autism appears to have
stabilised."
They researchers also dismissed claims that the vaccine can cause
developmental or bowel problems in children.
"The claims that MMR vaccine is involved in the initiation of
autism, and/or with regression, and/or with bowel problems
associated with autism are not supported by any credible scientific
evidence, while there is compelling and increasing evidence showing
no association."
The researchers said controversial research published in 1997,
which suggested a link between the MMR vaccine and autism, appeared
to have influenced parents.
Before the study was published, just two out of 46 parents had
suggested the vaccine had caused autism in their child.
However, afterwards it was cited in six out of 30 cases.
"Before August 1997, parents incriminated trigger factors such as
domestic stress, seizures or viral illness.
"Post 1997, parents were more likely to attribute regression to
vaccination, especially the MMR vaccine," the researchers said.
The UK's National Autistic Society welcomed the study.
Stuart Notholt, its director of policy, said it was difficult to
get accurate figures on the incidence of autism.
"Data on the numbers affected by autistic spectrum disorders
continue to be sparse and it has been difficult to compare current
numbers with figures from earlier years," he said.
However, he said the number of new cases could be expected to
level out if doctors were becoming more aware of the condition and
if there was no external cause, such as a vaccine.
"It might be expected that with growing familiarity with autistic
spectrum disorders, over a period of time, provided there were no
external factors influencing onset, prevalence figures would begin
to level out."
Has your opinion of the MMR vaccine changed? Send us your
experiences and views on this story. A selection will be published
below.
Click here to send your comments
Regardless of the results of the new study, if parents want their
children to have single jabs, then they should be given the choice.
Jessica Shaughnessy, Chester, England
 |
Measles can leave children deaf, blind,
brain-damaged and in the worst cases, they
die
|
My views on the MMR vaccine haven't changed a bit. I an
completely unconvinced that its connected to autism, and I'm very
concerned that gullible parents are exposing their children to very
unpleasant childhood diseases by refusing to have the MMR. My
daughter is 9 months old, and she will definitely receive the
vaccine when it is due. People have forgotten just how lethal
diseases like measles can be. Before the vaccines, the population
had developed a lot of resistance to measles and most children just
got a mild form, and were spotty - however, its not just about
spots, measles can leave children deaf, blind, brain-damaged and in
the worst cases, they die. Levels of MMR vaccination are so low in
some areas now, that there is a very real danger of a measles
epidemic similar to the one in Dublin some years back. I cannot and
will not subject my daughter to that danger.
S. Harris, Milton Keynes, UK
Both my children have had the MMR Vaccine. Each time there was a
lot on the news about dangers of having this Vaccine. I must admit I
did feel more anxious about having my little boy, who is 6,
vaccinated purely because of the statistics on boys and autism. The
fact that I was an older mum (33) concerned me slightly more. When
these reports are published why do they not show what exactly has
been studied / considered? Surely with this information people would
not automatically blame the MMR for their child's disability
S Sutton, Manchester
My nephew started having fits days after having the MMR jab. He
is now autistic, so I believe there is a link. My girlfriend is
pregnant and my child is due in 6 weeks. No child of mine will ever
have the MMR jab
Jamie, Newcastle
My Son was born with Asperger's, a mild form of autism, he did
not contract it through MMR. These insane media scares are pathetic
and severely detrimental. I recall the scare about the contraceptive
pill that caused women to stop taking them. This led to a
catastrophic increase in the number of abortions. Then people wonder
why there the NHS is struggling. Imagine if there was an epidemic,
people would soon be rushing for help for their children, again at
the cost of the NHS. It is time these scares were made illegal. I
firmly believe the sole reason for autism increase is due to the
fact that since the early nineties people have begun to sit up and
take notice, realising that these children are different and not
just naughty.
Catherine Hewitt, Nottingham England
I represent a group of families in Halton who have children with
autism. Many of them are convinced of the link with MMR as their
child regressed immediately after the vaccine from an apparently
normal able bodied child into deeply autistic behaviour.
As far as levelling out is concerned, in our area the incidences
of autism are still rising dramatically as is the case of children
with disabilities in general. Is there an environmental link also as
our local air and land is heavily polluted by many years of chemical
production?
Ciaran Shanahan, Secretary of HAFS (Halton Autistic Family
Support Group), Halton, Cheshire
The seriously wrong story of 6 years ago has been given massive
long-term publicity by the Media. At last it is now entirely
disproved. It is time the Media asked themselves how they could have
better handled the story.
Les Culank, Cambridge UK
 |
I
would be much happier if the single
vaccination was more widely available
|
My son is now 3 and I have been trying to decide whether to give
him the MMR for over 2 years now. Every time I make my mind up one
way or the other I hear something in the news or from friends that
makes me unsure again. Again researchers are telling us that the MMR
is 'harmless', but some people are just too afraid of putting their
child at risk of autism... even though we then put them at risk of
other illnesses. I would be much happier if the single vaccination
was more widely available - when I phoned local clinics to enquire
about this they told me I'd never get the single vaccines in the UK
and would have to go abroad! I'm happy to pay - just give people the
choice.
Alicia, Ipswich, UK
Once I discovered that the original study was based on the
assumption that autism is caused by a nutritional deficiency, I felt
far more secure about vaccinating my children. The link between
autism and any deficiency in the diet is spurious at best - why
don't malnourished children in developing countries have a higher
rate of autism, if that was the case? Nobody wants to do anything to
harm their children, and since BSE they do not trust the government,
which is why this MMR scare will run and run. The original claims
can never be disproven to the satisfaction of everyone - but the
fact remains that vaccination has saved literally millions of lives,
and the chances of any child, vaccinated or not, developing autism
for any reason is vanishingly small when compared with the risk from
measles, mumps and rubella.
Victoria, UK
I still feel that there was a 'rogue' batch of MMR vaccinations
here in South Wales. The rise in the number of reported cases of
autism and asperger's syndrome, does not reassure me that the
vaccination is safe. Although I am a firm believer that 'some' MMR
batches are safe.
Tracey, South Wales
My daughter had the single dose measles and now is going to have
the rest done as single dose. I believe that there is no smoke
without fire in this case, I have no regrets at all going down the
road of the single dose and wouldn't have again should we have
another child. At the end of the day you do what you think is best
for the safety of your child and not what some stuffed shirt in the
government tells you to do.
Andy, Manchester,UK