Thu, July 17, 2003
Vaccine lottery called symptom
of Ontario's failing public-health system
By COLIN PERKEL
TORONTO (CP) - A cash-strapped health unit in Ontario has
decided to run a vaccination lottery as a way of immunizing at
least some children against two dreaded diseases, but critics
say it's a sign of a badly underfunded public health system.
The lottery for free vaccines against pneumonia and
meningitis run by the Haliburton Kawartha Pine Ridge health
unit is open to all children in the district aged two to four
but only 400 will be randomly selected.
That means about 3,600 others will be out of luck if all
those in the age group want the shots.
A statement from the health unit describes the motivation
for the lottery.
"Since the government forces parents to gamble with their
children's health by not covering the cost, we thought we
would also give parents a chance to gamble and hopefully win a
chance to protect their children."
Sharon Thompson, director of communicable diseases for the
health unit, said in an interview Thursday it's the best they
can do with the $50,000 the board of health has taken out of
its reserves for vaccinations.
"We had a fixed dollar value to spend on vaccines and it
would not cover every child in our area," said Thompson.
"The main concern was equity of access for the parents."
The Canadian Pediatric Society and the National Advisory
Committee on Immunization have recommended all children be
vaccinated against the meningococcal and pneumococcal
infections.
Given the seriousness of the illnesses, the vaccines are
also considered highly cost-effective. Most other provinces do
fund immunization programs for children.
New Democrat Michael Prue said government underfunding has
left health units stretched to the point they can't carry out
their most important functions.
"It's symptomatic of a health system in decline is what it
is," said Prue.
The government could pay to immunize all kids with the
money its spending on tax breaks for seniors and private
schools, he said.
"It's a question of priorities."
An aide to Health Minister Tony Clement said Ontario does
fund several vaccination programs, such as one against the
influenza, mumps and measles, but only pays for pneumonia and
meningitis if there's an outbreak.
"The plan now is to respond to outbreaks with immunization
for anyone who might be at risk," said Paul Cantin.
In a position paper this month, Ontario's medical officers
of health backed a call for such a program by noting that
forcing parents to pick up the tab for the shots can be
prohibitive.
It costs up to $800 to vaccinate a child against
meningitis, pneumonia and chicken pox.
"Ontario's children thus face inequalities compared to
children in other parts of Canada as well as within Ontario,"
the health officials said.
Thompson said she remembers a fatal outbreak of meningitis
several years ago where the health unit suddenly found itself
scrambling to vaccinate 22,000 children in one three-week
period.
"The expense of vaccinating children under those conditions
and the hysteria is something that can clearly be avoided,"
said Thompson.