Young women who eat a lot of meat,
cheese and other foods rich in animal fat may be
increasing their risk of breast cancer, a new
study has found.
Researchers have long suspected
a link between fatty diets and breast cancer, but
previous studies couldn't establish one. This
study, a large one involving more than 90,000
nurses, found no link between breast cancer and
fats from plants, such as olive oil. But it did
find that women who ate more red meat and high-fat
dairy products showed a modestly increased risk of
getting the disease.
"If you think about the risk factors for breast
cancer, women don't have many choices to modify
those risk factors. Diet is something you can
change," said Eunyoung Cho, of Brigham and Women's
Hospital in Boston, Mass., and Harvard Medical
School.
The study is significant because it involved so
many women, and because they were so young, aged
26 to 46 years.
Most previous studies involved postmenopausal
women.
Breast cancer is more common after the age of
50, but it may take years to develop, and
researchers have been trying to identify factors
earlier in life that may play a role. This study
suggests that what women eat in their 20s, 30s and
40s may be important.
Animal fat is only one piece of the breast
cancer puzzle. Family history is important in a
disease that can have a genetic component. Women
who started their menstrual periods early have a
higher risk, as do those who didn't get pregnant
until later in life or never have children.
Breast-feeding may offer some protection.
Another study found that women who breast-fed
infants for at least 16 months have a reduced
risk.
In this study, the women filled out a detailed
questionnaire about their eating habits, first in
1991, then again in 1995.
The researchers divided them into five
different groups, based on their intake of animal
fat.
By 1999, 714 of the women had developed breast
cancer; 134 in the high-fat group and 123 in the
low-fat group. Dr. Cho said that even though this
may seem like a small difference, it is
significant.
"When we compared women in the high-fat-intake
group with women in the lowest intake group, those
with the highest intake had a 33 per cent greater
risk of breast cancer," she said in an interview.
She described this as a moderate increase in
risk, but said her study indicates it might be
wise for young women to decrease the animal fat in
their diets. There is another good reason for
taking this step, she said.
Reducing the animal fat you eat also reduces
the risk of heart disease.
The women in the study who were most at risk
obtained about 23 per cent of their total calories
from fat, compared to 12 per cent in the lower
risk group.
It is not clear why a diet high in animal fat
would increase the risk of cancer, Dr. Cho said.
In fact, it may be that other substances found in
foods containing animal fat are the culprits, not
the fat itself.