02:00 AM Jun. 30, 2003 PT
Bacteria-eating viruses could be the answer to antibiotic resistance, and
the first treatment to use the therapy could be available by 2004.
Half a century ago, antibiotics revolutionized medicine by turning many
once-deadly infections like tuberculosis into minor impediments. But
overuse is rapidly rendering antibiotics ineffective, and scientists know
they need a replacement fast. One of the most promising options is one
that's been used in Eastern Europe and Russia for decades:
bacteriophage therapy.
The word bacteriophage comes from bacterium, plus the Greek
phagein, to eat. Phages, as they're also called, were never
thoroughly studied as therapies in the West, mainly because antibiotics
proved to be so effective. But with resistance mounting fast, researchers
have begun aggressively studying phage therapy, and the first treatment
could enter the Western market as soon as 2004.
"The beauty is that the phage will only latch onto and destroy (one)
strain of bacteria and leaves all the good bacteria unharmed," said Denise
Curnow, CEO of
Novolytics, a U.K. company working on a prophylactic to prevent
staph infection.
Staph, short for Staphylococcus aureus bacteria, is very
common in hospitals. It's carried on the skin and in the nasal passages,
and was once a major problem for surgery patients. Antibiotics solved that
problem, but
antibiotic resistance to those commonly used against staph infection
is increasing.
The cream Novolytics is developing would kill staph infection in the
nasal passages and prevent its spread. It could also be rubbed on
instruments such as catheters to prevent infection. They're beginning the
second of the three phases of clinical trials necessary for approval in
the United Kingdom, and plan to repeat the process for approval in the
United States. Tests so far have been promising, Curnow said. It works,
she said, and there are no side effects. They'll have more results by
fall, she said.
"I suppose some of the best solutions are the most elegant," she said.
Felix d'Herelle of the Pasteur Institute in France dubbed the
bacteria-eaters "bacteriophages" in 1917. They're one of the simplest life
forms on earth, with a head made of DNA, and spidery legs that grab
bacterium. Phages inject bacteria with their DNA, and the bacteria rapidly
make copies of the phage until the bacteria explodes. The explosion
launches hundreds of new phage particles into the infected area.
The Republic of Georgia uses phage therapy regularly as a treatment for
many types of infections.
"They basically don't cut off feet because of diabetic ulcers in
Georgia because their staph phage works so well," said Elizabeth Kutter,
referring to the fact that such infections often lead to amputations in
the West. Kutter is the director
bacteriophage research at Evergreen State College in Olympia,
Washington.
Kutter has helped at least two patients with seemingly untreatable
infections get well by traveling to the
Tblisi clinic in
the Republic of Georgia for treatment.
While phage treatments are common and effective there, the Western
world requires more rigorous proof that therapies are safe and effective.
So companies like Novolytics, Intralytix, Exponential Biotherapies and
GangaGen have taken a commercial interest in taking phage treatments
through the necessary testing and marketing.
One potential drawback is that phage therapies might be too specific
for widespread use against infection, according to Carl Merril, a senior
investigator at the National Institutes of
Health. For example, one phage might work for one strain of
Streptococcus pneumoniae (the most common type of pneumonia) but not
for the 27 others.
One solution is to make a "cocktail" treatment containing several
phages, but it remains to be seen how useful that approach will be.
The beauty of antibiotics was that any one antibiotic worked for many
different types of infection. But it is also turning into their downfall,
because they also kill good bacteria that humans need to remain healthy.
Moreover, bacteria are good at finding ways to outsmart the drugs.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, nearly 2
million people in the United States acquire an infection while in a
hospital every year, and 90,000 of them die. More than 70 percent of the
bacteria that cause these infections are resistant to at least one of the
antibiotics commonly used to treat them.
Phage therapies are at the opposite end of the spectrum. They kill the
bacteria they're meant to almost without fail, and bacteria don't become
resistant nearly as often. However, Merril cautioned, "Given the narrow
host range of phage, you can't use it like penicillin."
Still, Kutter and others believe phage therapy is the greatest hope
against antibiotic resistance. Kutter will host the 15th annual
bacteriophage conference from July 23-27 at Evergreen, and expects about
100 researchers from 13 countries.