Autism is one of the most
common developmental disabilities in children [boxh] more common than
Down syndrome [boxh]
yet many health care professionals aren't aware of its
effects. Autism affects anywhere from 1 in 200 to 1 in 1,000
children. 1-5
Family and pediatric nurse practitioners can
expect to diagnose or treat at least one case during their
careers. 4
, 6 As primary care providers
(PCPs), nurse practitioners (NPs) should screen all children
for developmental delays. The family may also look to NPs to
help guide them through the maze of treatment options that are
available once the diagnosis of autism has been confirmed.
Awareness of current
screening, diagnostic, and treatment methods increases the
chance of early intervention, which can lead to better
outcomes.
Profiling the Disorder
Autism is a lifelong
condition that is about four times more prevalent in boys and
does not seem influenced by racial, ethnic, or psychosocial
status. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders (DSM-IV-TR) lists autistic disorder as one of five
disorders with similar symptoms under the umbrella diagnosis
of pervasive developmental disorders. 7
The other four are pervasive developmental disorder-not
otherwise specified (PDD-NOS), Asperger syndrome, Rett's
disorder, and childhood disintegrative disorder.
Researchers see autism as a
biologically-based disorder of the brain defined by the
presence or absence of a constellation of symptoms. 7
Structural abnormalities usually exist, especially in
the size and number of Purkinje and neuronal cells within the
cerebellum, which brain scans detect. 8 ,
9 Evidence of these
abnormalities implies that the etiology occurs early in
prenatal development.
2 , 10
Patterns of autism or related disabilities exist in some
families and suggest a genetic basis. Although genetic
research looks promising, a direct link hasn't been identified
and environmental influences may also play a role.
Despite publicized claims
that vaccinations can trigger autism, researchers have yet to
prove any connection.
11 Some parents
associate vaccinations, particularly the measles-mumps-rubella
(MMR) vaccination, or their constituent substances, such as
mercury, with the onset of autistic symptoms. A substantial
increase in autism diagnoses, which may partly owe to wider
recognition and broader diagnostic criteria, fuel this
controversy. Several studies on this issue are underway, and
their findings could allay parents' fears. Parents with strong
objections to vaccinations may choose to delay them until
after their child is 24 months old, or request separate
administration of combined vaccinations.
Diagnosis Delays
Although symptoms typically
appear by age 3, autism often remains undiagnosed until age 4
or even later, although an increasing number of children are
diagnosed before the age of 3. Parents and childcare workers
usually first notice delays in language, play, or social
interaction when affected children are between the ages of 18
to 30 months. Some parents may notice symptoms earlier.
Diagnostic delays often occur because of the diverse
expression of autism, unavailability of appropriate screening
tools, and concerns about labeling or incorrect diagnosis. 3 ,
12
Delays in diagnosis may
also occur because fewer than 30% of primary care providers
perform standardized screening for developmental delays during
well-child visits.
3 In more than 1,200 United Kingdom
families who felt 'something was wrong' with their child,
providers diagnosed fewer than 10 percent of the children
during initial presentation.
13
Families will look to
providers to guide them through treatment options when they
have a confirmed diagnosis. Many parents reported that
providers didn't offer any information about their child's
problems or names of support groups, nor did providers refer
them for early intervention. Many said schools and other
parents, not health care workers, provided the most
assistance.
13
Signs and Symptoms
Children with autism often
present with a wide variety of symptoms and characteristics
that range from mild to severe (see Table: '
Common Characteristics of Children with Autism ').
Although no single developmental deficit or behavior
characteristic exists for all children with autism, most will
have some degree of impairment in the ability to use joint
attention (the ability to use eye contact and pointing for the
social purpose of sharing experiences with others) and pretend
play. 1
|
Common Characteristics of
Children with Autism
|
Children with autism have
deficiencies in verbal and non-verbal communication, social
interaction, and play. They may also perform repetitive body
movements, have unusual responses to people or attachments to
objects, resist changes in routines, and behave aggressively
or injure themselves. Affected children may exhibit any
combination of these behaviors with any degree of severity.
When they reach school age, children with autism have a
variable range of academic skills.
14
The prognosis for children
with autism is often uncertain. Some symptoms may lessen as
the child ages, others may require specialized support and
supervised, structured care. Studies show that the most
important factor in determining intellectual progress is the
overall level of ability.
15
Screening and Diagnosis
Early diagnosis and
intervention may produce better outcomes, but diagnosing
autism during a primary care visit can be challenging. Early
intervention begins with proper screening. First, providers
should screen all children for developmental progress.
Developmental surveillance 'should include social-emotional
milestones in addition to the more traditional motor,
cognitive, and language ones.'
1
Researchers have found that
the traditional screening tool, the Denver Developmental
Screening Test-II (DDST-II), is lacking in sensitivity and
specificity. Researchers report that the Ages and Stages
Questionnaire, BRIGANCE Screens, Child Development
Inventories, and Parents Evaluations of Developmental Status
are more sensitive for general screening. 3
Parental concerns regarding
speech and language development, behavior, or other
developmental issues help detect global deficits and should
prompt providers to perform more comprehensive testing.
Absence of babbling by 12 months, gesturing by 12 months,
single words by 16 months, and two-word spontaneous phrases by
24 months may signal a developmental disability, as is loss of
language or social skills at any age. 3
Take a medical history,
which should include the child's prenatal, labor and delivery,
and early neonatal periods, as well as language and motor
developmental milestones. Ask parents when they first became
concerned about their child and why. Ask them about unusual
aspects of the child's early development and concerns they may
have.
Evaluate the child's
medical conditions, such as hearing or visual impairments,
Fragile X syndrome, mental retardation, and use of
behavior-modifying medications or interventions. Obtain
previous educational evaluations, standardized rating scales,
teacher or care provider reports, and other pertinent
information.
Conduct a physical
examination, including a detailed neurologic examination, to
help identify treatable conditions or those frequently
associated with autism, such as seizure disorders, Fragile X
syndrome, or tuberous sclerosis. Order laboratory examinations
if the child's history and clinical presentation indicate
them.
All children with
developmental delays, particularly language and social delays,
should receive a formal audiologic and visual evaluation,
comprehensive speech and language evaluation, and serum lead
level test. Consider ordering other studies if the child's
history and physical exam merit them and if the results will
aid in genetic counseling and management options.
The child should be
screened specifically for autism if he fails a routine
developmental surveillance. This may be done with either an
autism screening instrument (see Table: '
Autism Diagnostic Tools ') or, if you can't obtain
an autism-specific instrument, systematically inquire about
language and social-emotional development, joint attention,
and pretend play with a screening questionnaire (see Table: '
Important Screening Questions for Parents ').
|
Autism Diagnostic Tools
|
|
Important Screening
Questions for Parents
|
If the child fails the
autism-specific screen, a formal evaluation should be
performed. This evaluation should differentiate autism from
other developmental disorders. Diagnosis stems from
observations of the child's communication, behavior, and
development and occurs when a specific number of
characteristics are present in inappropriate ranges for that
age. A multidisciplinary team, which may include a
developmental pediatrician, child psychologist,
speech-language expert, and an occupational and physical
therapist with autism knowledge, should evaluate the
observations, which should take place in home, school, and
clinical settings.
A specialist or team of
specialists should complete psychological and psychiatric
examinations. Specialists should be knowledgeable regarding
autism and other pervasive developmental disorders, as well as
mental retardation, selective mutism, obsessive-compulsive
disorder, and social anxiety disorder.
Cognitive ability needs to
be assessed with separate estimates of verbal IQ (VIQ) and
nonverbal (performance) IQ (PIQ). Many children will
demonstrate a pattern of PIQ higher than VIQ; 3
the PIQ-VIQ split, however, is severity-dependent.
Formal intelligence testing can be challenging, and results
may not be reliable.
6
DSM criteria are geared to
children 3 years and older and preliminary diagnoses may need
revision if additional symptoms appear. Other screening tools
exist for autism or are in development (see Table: '
Sample of Common Autism Screening Tools ').
|
Sample of Common Autism
Screening Tools
|
At this time, a
multidisciplinary team establishes optimal intervention
strategies. Because of the required time, special training,
and multidisciplinary approach, many PCPs may refer the child
to more experienced clinicians.
Several diagnostic tools
can help practitioners make an accurate diagnosis. Autism
specialists typically use one or more diagnostic tools (see
Table: 'Autism Diagnostic Tools'). The child should receive a
re-evaluation within one year and regularly thereafter to
track developmental changes.
Treating Autism
Pediatric literature
doesn't contain any medical cures, guidelines, or consensus
for treating autism.
6 However, most current
treatments focus on improving overall function. Typically,
this goal involves enrolling the child in an appropriate and
intensive early intervention program to promote development of
communication, social, adaptive, behavioral, and academic
skills. These programs can also decrease maladaptive and
repetitive behaviors, and help the family manage stress by
providing information about community resources, such as
respite care and support groups.
Clinicians should tailor
interventions to developmental and behavioral needs as well as
the family's coping style and resources. Interventions may
include parent education and support, highly structured social
play, individualized school-based education, behavior
management and training, medical treatment, and respite.
Parents of children who have just received an autism diagnosis
may find help through talking with other parents of autistic
children. 16
Help parents find a 'parent to parent'
organization, and give them the contact information for a
local Autism Society of America chapter.
The federal government
mandates age-appropriate early intervention and school
programs, which are often based on a developmental delay
rather than a specific diagnosis. The federal Individuals with
Disabilities Education Act of 1990 (and subsequent revisions),
mandates 'appropriate' educational plans for children with
developmental disabilities or delays and allocates specific
rights to their parents. Services include speech-language
therapy and occupational and physical therapy for preschool
and school-aged children.
Several treatments
consistently benefit children with autism. The treatments
mentioned here don't indicate exclusive treatment, nor do they
serve as a standard of care. Although specialists will likely
direct the care of a child with autism, remain actively
involved, even if you disagree with the family's treatment
decisions.
|
Common Misperceptions of
Autism
|
Behavioral Technology and Social Skills
Training
Behavioral training and
management is the cornerstone of treating autism at any age.
Behavior management and structured teaching of skills help to
prevent undesirable behaviors and help caregivers more clearly
teach and give directions to children with autism. Discrete
trial training is one form of applied behavior analysis. It
involves intensive, one-on-one teaching so children learn
small parts of behaviors or skills in short, repeated
sessions. As a child learns skills, the teacher adds new ones
in carefully planned sequences.
The 'social story' uses
scripted scenarios to help children with autism understand and
follow specified social protocols.
17 Another approach
uses symbols or pictures to demonstrate appropriate and
inappropriate behaviors.
Children with autism should
be in childcare centers and classrooms with
typically-developing children so they can model desirable
behaviors. A teacher can extend this modeling by creating a
'circle of friends,' in which she invites children to join a
circle with an autistic child. The teacher then encourages the
children to express concerns about the difficulties the child
is having and help create solutions.
|
Checklist for Autism in Toddlers (CHAT)
|
Habilitative Services
Communication training
involving preverbal and verbal communication and occupational
and physical therapy are also essential for managing autism.
These are most effective when interwoven throughout a total
program. Because children with autism often have a core
deficit in functional communication, they typically need
intensive intervention to develop receptive and expressive
communication.
Based upon behavioral
principles, speech therapy may focus on acquiring language
skills or helping the child communicate more effectively by
correcting errors in semantics or pragmatics. Gestural,
verbal, pictorial, and technological systems and discrete
trial training can effectively teach language. Each child
needs an individualized program, with family and teacher
support, to learn communication. Careful assessment is
critical, as well as skilled training and commitment of the
adults who will use the system with the child. 14
Occupational and physical therapy can help address any
coordination concerns and motor deficits.
Alternative Therapies
Unconventional treatments
abound partly because no medical cure exists for autism. Many
parents pursue alternative therapies because of a desire to
try almost anything that might help, claims of improvements
from other families, or rising skepticism regarding
scientifically-based treatments. Become familiar with the more
popular alternative therapy treatments for autism, such as
unconventional diets, vitamin supplementation, sensory
integration, and vision treatments. Approach parents' choices
with objectivity and compassion.
Tell parents that many
people are urging scientific evaluation of treatments. Advise
that they should be skeptical of any treatment-especially
those touted as a 'cure,' a method that will lead to
'recovery,' or one that will benefit all who have autism.
Encourage parents to speak with a health care provider and ask
themselves these questions before starting any proposed
treatment:
18
-
Could the treatment
harm my child?
-
How will failure of
the treatment affect my child and family?
-
Does the treatment
have scientific validation?
-
Do specified
assessment procedures exist?
-
Can we integrate the
treatment into the child's current program?
Changing Landscape
The diagnosis, management,
and understanding of autism changes dramatically as more
children receive diagnoses and more researchers study the
disorder. Periodically update your knowledge about autism to
provide early diagnosis, implement appropriate interventions,
and coordinate the system of care. For more information about
autism, consult local and national resources, such as the
Autism Society of America (http://www.autism-society.org).