Sarah Boseley
Tuesday July 1, 2003
The Guardian
Don Francis, founder and president of VaxGen, is not facing personal
hardship after the failure of AidsVax, the first Aids vaccine to
complete clinical trials.
Though he was working in a potentially unprofitable field -
vaccines for poor countries - he was able to pick up the sort of
remuneration that is common to successful businessmen in the United
States.
In 2001, according to VaxGen's annual report, Dr Francis was paid
$325,000, with a bonus of $72,000, but he sold stock worth $2.9m,
giving him a total take-home salary of $3.4m. He is thought to have
grossed $7m in three years from the company, while his colleague
Philip Berman, the inventor of AidsVax, grossed $5m.
In May 1998, the pair and one other executive were awarded a
"success bonus" of stock options worth $7.9m between them after the
VaxGen share price remained at $28 - four times the level when they
launched the company - for 30 consecutive days.
It may be enough to arouse the envy of lesser-paid scientists,
many of whom have been deeply critical of the ebullient talk at
VaxGen about the prospects for the vaccine. It is certainly rather
more than he would have earned earlier in his career as a government
researcher working for the Centres for Disease Control.
During his 21 years there, Dr Francis is said to have played an
important role in eradicating smallpox and led the effort to contain
the world's first outbreak of Ebola. He was also one of the two
principal investigators working on the clinical trials for a
successful vaccine for hepatitis B.
On his retirement in 1992 from the CDC, he began to work with the
major genetic engineering company Genentech, which in 1995 abandoned
work on a tentative Aids vaccine and passed the plans to him.
He set up VaxGen specifically to develop it and threw himself
into the effort to drum up financial backing and sell the idea.
A year ago, at the International Aids conference in Barcelona, Dr
Francis told the Guardian he was convinced AidsVax would work
because it had worked in chimpanzees. However, he said: "I don't
know if it works for 20% of the people for two months or 80% of the
people for eight years."