|
Smallpox vaccine signup is less than expected
|
Josephine Marcotty and Maura Lerner
|
|
Star Tribune
|
|
|
|
Published Jan. 18, 2003
|
VAC18
|
The number of health care workers in Minnesota lining up to get the
smallpox vaccine is falling short of expectations, according to hospitals
and public health agencies.
Even as concerns about the plan continued to build in Minnesota and
nationwide, federal officials said they will move ahead as scheduled.
The Minnesota Health Department said Friday that it still has time to
recruit more volunteers before the first round of vaccinations begins,
possibly as early as next month. About 50 hospitals across the state had
estimated earlier that as many as 5,300 workers would get vaccinated -- a
number that may prove unrealistic.
At St. Cloud Hospital, for example, only 22 health workers have
volunteered so far for the smallpox vaccines -- about one-tenth of the 210
originally projected, said spokeswoman Jeanine Nistler. However, some
hospitals said they are on track.
Officials of some unions and hospitals said employees are worried about
the risk of the vaccine, and the financial consequences if they get sick.
"I think that people really are a little unsure of what's the right thing
to do," said Anne Sonnee, spokeswoman for HealthEast Care System,
which owns St. Joseph's Hospital in St. Paul, St. John's Hospital in
Maplewood and Woodwinds Medical Campus in Woodbury.
On Friday, the Institute of Medicine, an advisory group to the federal
government, urged federal health officials to proceed more cautiously and
deliberately. It said the government should respond to concerns about how
people will be compensated for medical expenses and other losses, and it
should clarify the risks to potential volunteers.
Also this week, three national health care unions called on the
government to delay the plan until those concerns are resolved.
Yet officials from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
(CDC) responded Friday by saying that they will move forward as planned, and
begin shipping the vaccine Tuesday.
"We intend to make this program happen on time," said Dr. Julie
Gerberding, CDC director. "We . . . live in a dangerous world these days
where a terrorist attack with smallpox is possible. We have to protect the
people."
The CDC has made "heroic efforts" to protect health care workers who get
the vaccine, she said. At first, only those who would care for patients in a
smallpox outbreak will be eligible for the vaccine. Later, it would be
offered to other health care and emergency workers and eventually to the
public.
She declined to say how many volunteers have stepped forward nationally,
but she said that states have requested 50,000 doses of vaccine for the
first round of vaccinations, which could begin nationally as soon as next
week. So far 11 states have asked the CDC to begin shipping the vaccine, but
she declined to say which ones.
Minnesota health officials said they have not yet requested a shipment.
Buddy Ferguson, spokesman for the state Health Department, said that
hospitals are revising their estimates, and that the number to be vaccinated
could change.
"I don't think we are concerned at this point that we won't be able to
vaccinate enough people," he added.
Fairview Health Services, which operates seven hospitals, has seen fewer
volunteers than predicted.
"Generally we have not hit our goal," said Alison Page, Fairview's vice
president for patient safety.
Although she wouldn't disclose the number of volunteers, she said
officials had predicted 100 to 200 at each eligible hospital.
"Certainly we want our employees to be very careful," she said. At the
same time, "we are not anticipating at this point any of our hospitals
pulling out of the process."
Meanwhile, three east metro counties had expected 1,500 volunteers from
among their public health workers; about 1,000 have stepped forward so far,
said Lillian McDonald of the St. Paul-Ramsey County Health Department.
In Duluth, a tuberculosis case forced two hospitals to put off recruiting
volunteers for the smallpox vaccine. St. Mary's and Miller-Dwan hospitals
soon will test health workers for TB because a doctor fell ill in December.
The smallpox vaccine can taint the results, said Dr. Timothy Burke, medical
epidemiologist for the hospitals. For now, the TB tests should take
priority, he said, "because that's something that's real, it's right here,
and the smallpox is theoretical."
Some hospitals, though, say they're on track to meet their goals. Abbott
Northwestern in Minneapolis already has about 100 volunteers, and Hennepin
County Medical Center in Minneapolis is close to meeting its goal, officials
say.
In Minnesota, the nurses union is advising members to do their homework
before making a decision. "Before you volunteer for anything, make sure
you're informed and educated on the risks," said Walter Frederickson, head
of labor relations for the Minnesota Nurses Association. "Because of the
voluntary nature, it's your risk."
The American Nurses Association called on President Bush Friday to delay
the smallpox plan, joining two national unions: the Service Employees
International Union and the American Federation of State County and
Municipal Employees.
It is not certain how many are reluctant to volunteer because of the
vaccine's health risks or because their health status precludes them from
getting the vaccine. Because vaccinated people can shed the virus, family
members also may be at risk.
That does not stop some, however.
"I have to make sure that the [vaccination] site stays covered," said
Jeff Allen, a St. Paul-Ramsey County nurse who has volunteered for the
vaccination. He said he discussed the risks with his children and told them,
"If we are sitting on couch snuggling, we have to be careful."
Vaccine experts say 20 to 30 percent of the population could be
ineligible because of medical conditions, such as eczema or pregnancy.
Even if the number of volunteers in Minnesota is lower than expected, it
would not handicap the state's efforts to prepare for a bioterrorist attack,
said Ferguson of the Health Department.
"The idea here is to have minimal numbers of people vaccinated in advance
of an actual event so they could respond to it," he said. "But again, you
can vaccinate people even after they've been exposed to smallpox. That's the
backup."
-- Staff writer Jill Burcum contributed to this story.
-- Josphine Marcotty is at
marcotty@startribune.com.--
Maura Lerner is at
mlerner@startribune.com.
|