Filed at 1:23 p.m. ET
LONDON (Reuters) - Switzerland's Roche Holding AG (ROCZg.VX) on Monday
priced its new HIV drug Fuzeon at a record-breaking 18,980 euros ($20,570) a
year, fueling controversy about the cost of AIDS treatments.
Roche said the high cost -- more than double the cost of other HIV/AIDS
drugs on the market -- reflected the complexity of manufacturing the
revolutionary product, involving more than 100 production steps.
Fuzeon is the first in a new class of drugs known as fusion inhibitors
designed for people resistant to other AIDS medicines and is expected to be
approved next month.
Unlike existing drugs that work inside the cell, it blocks HIV from
entering healthy human immune cells.
``This drug is 10 times more complex to manufacture than the next most
complex class of drug in the HIV arena, which is the protease inhibitors,''
David Reddy, head of Roche's HIV business, told Reuters in a telephone
interview.
The high price took industry analysts by surprise.
Lehman Brothers, which had expected a cost of $15,000, said the higher
figure might trigger upgrades to Fuzeon sales forecasts.
``This price is clearly above our expectations and shows that the limited
amount that can be produced is supposed to be sold at the highest possible
price in the industrialized countries,'' added Patrick Burgermeister of
Zuercher Kantonalbank.
Reddy said Fuzeon, also known as T-20, had cost 840 million Swiss francs
to develop, excluding marketing expenses. More than half of was accounted
for by clinical trials and most of the rest reflected investment in
specialist manufacturing. Pure research costs were only around one percent.
Reddy declined to comment on the profit margin that Roche would enjoy on
sales of Fuzeon, which it believes could eventually have peak annual sales
of up to one billion francs ($740 million).
The cost of the medicine will be similar in the United States, he added.
PRODUCTION DIFFICULTIES
The twice-daily injection is given in combination with existing drugs and
is expected to win marketing approval from regulators in Europe in the
coming weeks and in the United States by March 16.
In the meantime, however, Roche is launching a pre-license special-access
program under which the drug will be available in certain European Union
countries. Reddy said it was not yet clear which countries would participate
in the scheme or how many patients would be involved.
Reddy said he did not envisage Fuzeon ever being suitable for use in
Africa -- the epicenter of the global AIDS pandemic -- given its very high
cost of production.
Global pharmaceutical companies, including Roche, have bowed to pressure
from humanitarian groups in recent years to slash the cost of life-saving
AIDS drugs in Africa and other poor countries. But Reddy said Fuzeon was in
a different category.
``Even if we were to price this drug at cost, it is not going to be the
type of drug that is suitable for the developing world,'' he said.
``We've thought long and hard about the price of this and we're coming
through with something that we really believe is fair, based upon what we've
had to invest and the risks that we've taken.''
Sidney Wolfe, director of Public Citizen Health Research Group, said the
pharmaceutical industry has long exaggerated the cost of bringing new drugs
to market to justify high prices, and ``it is likely Roche is doing the same
kind of thing'' with Fuzeon.
``This is an industry that is rapidly losing the respect of the public
because they are doing so much price gouging,'' Wolfe said.
Wolfe and other industry critics charge that there are drugs for all
kinds of serious illnesses where people who could be helped are being denied
the treatment because companies have chosen to try to make as much money as
possible.
Including those already involved in clinical trials and an early
free-access program, some 3,500 people worldwide are likely to be on Fuzeon
by the end of March.
The total should rise to 12,000-15,000 by the end of 2003 -- a lot fewer
than initially hoped, reflecting production difficulties at the main
manufacturing facility in Boulder, Colorado, where initial yields were lower
and cycle times longer than expected.
With analysts estimating that as many as 50,000 patients in North America
and Europe are resistant to other AIDS therapies and ready for Fuzeon,
demand is expected to outstrip supply for the foreseeable future.(TRMS.O) of
the U.S. expect to be able to supply the drug to a maximum of 32,000 people,
rising to 39,000 by the end of 2005.