A major new government study has found a much higher
prevalence of autism than studies done in the 1980s and early
'90s. The findings, though, still don't answer an important
question:Is autism truly on the rise?
Anecdotal reports from schools, doctors, service agencies and
parent groups suggests a dramatic increase in children with the
neurological disorder. But some experts say that could simply be a
result of growing awareness of the condition: More children are
being diagnosed because more people know about it.
The new study, done in the Atlanta area, found that 34 of every
10,000 children had autism or a related condition - compared with
a rate of 4 to 5 for every 10,000 reported in previous studies
conducted elsewhere in the last 20 years.
"The results certainly confirm the impression that many
professionals ... have that there are more children who fit the
criteria for autism," said Marshalyn Yeargin-Allsopp.
Yeargin-Allsopp is a medical epidemiologist with the National
Center on Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities at the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
She headed the study.
"It's clear there are more children being identified for
services," she said. "But it could be because services are
available, more children are being identified."
The data, published recently in the Journal of the American
Medical Association, supports several other recent studies in the
United States and Europe that found the rate of autism is higher
than once thought. Whether more children are developing autism
compared with previous generations is impossible to say, because
there are no long-term studies tracking trends.
Also, a broadening of the definition of autism to include
milder forms, and a better understanding of the disorder, have led
to more children being evaluated and more cases diagnosed.
The Atlanta study, which included children 3 to 10 years old in
the five-county metropolitan area in 1996, is part of a larger
effort by the CDC to get accurate regional measures of just how
big a problem autism is.
Autism is a brain disorder that hinders the ability to
communicate, interact and form relationships, and go about
day-to-day life. Because the disorder, which ranges from mild to
severe, tends to run in families, a strong genetic component is
suspected.
But researchers also are looking at other factors, such as
environmental influences, that may come into play. Some parents
suspect childhood vaccines, but medical scientists are skeptical
of that link.
Like the Atlanta study, the studies in Philadelphia and
elsewhere won't be able to answer whether the real incidence of
autism has increased, since there are no comparable previous
studies in those communities. However, they will establish a
baseline reading for future research.
"What matters is there are more children out there with
autistic disorders than we ever knew and they need services," said
Jennifer Pinto-Martin, an associate professor at the University of
Pennsylvania School of Nursing and a lead investigator for the CDC
study in the Philadelphia area.
The research, done in collaboration with Children's Hospital of
Philadelphia, has several components.
The first part will focus on children ages 3 to 8 in the
Philadelphia area. Using records from schools, doctors, medical
clinics and other official sources, researchers will determine the
rate of autism and related disorders.
In another study, being done in several areas around the
country, researchers will compare hundreds of autistic children
ages 3 to 5 with a matched group who don't have the disorder. The
goal is to find out what's similar or different between the
groups, which might point to some possible causes for autism.
The debate over whether something is fueling an epidemic of
autism was heightened in November with the release of a report in
California, which attempted to explain a dramatic increase in the
number of children getting services for autism in that state. The
report said the increase could not be explained away by a
broadening of criteria for the disorder, or the relocation of
families to California for the express purpose of getting help for
their children. It suggested other factors were at work.
Susan E. Levy, the medical director of the Regional Autism
Center at Children's Hospital in Philadelphia and a co-director of
the Philadelphia study, said that getting an accurate measure of
the scope of autism will lead to something more important:
"Getting a more objective count will help people predict and
plan better for what resources are needed," she said.