Delay
smallpox vaccines, nurses' union says
By EDWARD L. KENNEY
Staff reporter
02/05/2003
The Delaware
Nurses Association wants to delay plans to vaccinate medical workers here
against smallpox because of concerns that include possible transmission of
the disease to workers' families and patients.
The association joins a growing number of health-care organizations and
hospitals nationwide that have expressed reservations about President Bush's
plan to inoculate some of the nation's front-line health-care workers.
As part of its preparations for a war with Iraq or a terrorist attack,
the administration's voluntary plan calls for 500,000 health-care workers to
be vaccinated. A second phase of inoculations, which can prevent smallpox if
given before or shortly after exposure to the disease, is to include 10
million health-care workers, firefighters, police and emergency personnel.
The concerns are prompted in part by the possibility of rare but
potentially more serious side effects with the vaccine.
The inoculations are expected to begin this month. Nancy Rubino,
president of the Delaware nurses group, said the association wants the
inoculations delayed until its concerns are addressed. The group is worried
that others might inadvertently be infected by the live-virus vaccine and
that workers may not be compensated if they miss work because of the vaccine
or if they suffer side effects.
Experts estimate that 15 to 43 out of every million people being
vaccinated for the first time will face serious complications, and one or
two will die. The vaccine is particularly risky for pregnant women and those
with a history of skin problems or weak immune systems, including people
with HIV, cancer and those who have had an organ transplant. Recently
vaccinated people may also pose a threat of infection to others because for
several weeks they shed the live virus used in the vaccine.
Health workers who take the vaccine cover the injection area with a
special patch and are told to wash their hands frequently.
"We want them to have their questions answered so they can make an
informed decision," said Rubino, whose association represents about 600
nurses in Delaware.
Carol Stephens, 49, a pediatric nurse at Kent General Hospital in Dover,
said the call for a delay makes sense. "I need to know more about it," said
Stephens, who is not an association member. "I need to know how safe it is
as far as a reaction."
Not everyone seeks a delay. Dr. Sue Kost, 41, an emergency room doctor at
the Alfred I. du Pont Hospital for Children, said she would not hesitate to
get the shot.
"We used to routinely vaccinate everyone for smallpox," she said. "The
risks were exactly the same as they are right now. It hasn't become a more
dangerous vaccine, but I think people's perception of it is that it is a
more dangerous vaccine. I guess we're a more paranoid society these days."
But people who would be vaccinated have raised legitimate concerns, she
added, including worries about what happens in the aftermath of a bad
reaction to the vaccine. "If people miss work, will they be paid for that? I
agree there are things that aren't well thought out."
Kost said the hospital has not asked her to volunteer for the vaccine.
But hospital spokesman Jim Lardear said about 45 doctors, nurses and other
medical personnel have signed consent forms to receive the vaccine.
Carl Kanefsky, a spokesman for the Medical Society of Delaware, which
represents about 1,700 doctors, said he has not heard concerns from members
about the inoculation plan.
Division of Public Health spokeswoman Heidi Truschel-Light said the
state's vaccine shipment arrived here Tuesday, and she expects the
vaccinations to begin by March.
About 720 health-care workers in Delaware are to receive the vaccine,
including hospital emergency personnel, said Dr. Paul Silverman, chief of
disease prevention and control in the state's Division of Public Health.
That number is likely to dip because the program is voluntary, and some
workers might be excluded because they have conditions that would put them
at greater risk, he said.
All 50 states have submitted inoculation plans and their applications
have been accepted, said Llelwyn Grant, a spokes- man for the federal
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta. On Jan. 24, four
doctors were vaccinated in Connecticut, the first state to participate in
the program. But 16 volunteers who were scheduled to get shots with them
backed out.
Several national unions and other groups have criticized the program,
including the Service Employees International Union, with 750,000
health-care workers among its members. The American Nurses Association has
153,000 members.
The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, the nation's largest children's
hospital, also announced recently that it would not participate in the
program, joining at least 80 other hospitals nationwide that have made
similar decisions.
A recent USA Today/CNN Gallup poll reported that 53 percent of people
surveyed said hospitals that refuse to take part in the vaccination program
are "doing the right thing," compared with 39 percent who said it is wrong.
Eight percent said they had no opinion.
Before the program can begin in Delaware, Silverman said health-care
workers here must be trained to give the smallpox vaccination, which has not
been used routinely since 1972 and is injected differently than other
vaccines. One of those differences is the use of a two-pronged needle.
Health-care workers also must be trained to spot symptoms of an adverse
reaction to the smallpox vaccine, he said.
Dr. Charles Smith, president and chief executive officer of Christiana
Care Health System, said lectures about the disease already have become a
part of the program there. They were instituted because most doctors and
nurses in the United States have never seen cases of smallpox. The last
known case in the country was in 1949.
About 150 employees at Christiana Hospital and Wilmington Hospital, two
hospitals operated by the Christiana Care Health System, will be asked to
take the vaccine, he said.
Smith said he shares concerns about the possibility workers would suffer
adverse reactions to the shot, but serious complications are rare, steps
will be taken to minimize the risks and workers have the right to decline
the vaccination.
Reach Edward L. Kenney at 324-2891 or
ekenney@delawareonline.com.
|