Breaking News Archives
- each day's breaking news from December 1, 2003
(check here for breaking news you might have missed and breaking news that
didn't ever hit the "front page")
More News -
all the news most recently
posted on this website
All the News - a running tab of
everything posted on this website since October 29, 2003
click here to
download Adobe Reader click
here for Picks
of the Week click
here for the old "Recommended List"
To receive daily "top stories" updates, send an email to
sandym@touchngo.com with the words "subscribe
top stories" in the subject line. For today's
top stories, click
here.
Vaccine-related
December 12, 2003 -
Mandatory anthrax shots stir health fears, sap morale - USA Today - "The
Pentagon insists its vaccinations are safe. And for most people, they are...But
they aren't risk-free. Last year, the Food and Drug Administration warned that
5% to 35% of those who get shots could experience any of 40 side effects. About
6% of reactions can cause death, hospitalization or permanent disability."
Comment: 5% to 35% is a
rather large range. Is the FDA satisfied with such an inexact figure?
Should we be satisfied with such an inexact figure?
Comment:
According to the GAO, adverse reaction rates are
considerably higher than what is generally acknowledged: "The
Pentagon's mandatory anthrax shots caused adverse reactions in most recipients
and helped prompt many Air Force Reserve and Air National Guard members to
transfer to other units or leave the military between 1998 and 2000, according
to a survey by Congress's General Accounting Office (GAO)...The survey indicated
that 85% of troops who received an anthrax shot had an adverse reaction, a rate
far higher than the 30% claimed by the manufacturer in 2000, when the survey was
conducted. Sixteen percent of the survey respondents had either left the
military or changed their status, at least in part because of the vaccination
program."
Comment: Does the 6%
that potentially have had a serious reaction (i.e., "death,
hospitalization or permanent disability")
apply to the 85%? If so, that means that
around 5% of those who received the vaccine had a serious reaction to it.
For more on this check out
Direct Order
-
"Direct Order tells the story of members of the military who were ordered
against their will to receive the controversial anthrax vaccine. Years later,
after all the disturbing facts about the vaccine have surfaced, the US military
still intends to vaccinate all our troops." - documentary narrated by Michael
Douglas
Non-vaccine
from a non-VA - The Journal
Online - "On Nov. 26, Sen. Jeff Bingaman (D-N.H.) introduced a Sense of the
Senate resolution asking the Pentagon to reconsider its mandatory anthrax
vaccine. This welcome move is long overdue.
Senate Resolution 278
restates some acknowledged problems: (including that) a startling 84 percent of
personnel who had anthrax vaccine shots from 1998 to 2000 had side effects or
reactions, of which 24 percent were `systemic'"
Comment:
According to Senator Bingaman's resolution, 24% were systemic. That's 24%
of 84%, or approximately 20% of those receiving the vaccine!
December 11, 2003 -
Dearly deported -
Just months after Zeferino Colunga Sr. lost his GI son in Iraq, the
government arrested him and sent him back to Mexico. (requires subscription or
free one day pass) - www.salon.com - "Now
family members wonder if the deportation of Zeferino Colunga Sr. was connected
to their public demand for an independent investigation into the young soldier's
death."
December 11, 2003 -
Never mind the facts - Channel Five's new drama about the link between MMR
and autism makes great TV. But it gets the story, and the science, disastrously
wrong. How did we get to such a level of confusion and hysteria about this
vaccine? Ben Goldacre unravels the real MMR story - The Guardian, UK
Comment: As for "never minding the facts", it
all gets down to "who do you trust"? Do you trust the "facts" provided by
the vaccine manufacturers and anyone else who benefits financially from the use
of vaccines? Do you trust parents, who may not have proof, but do have
evidence implicating vaccines? Do you trust researchers and others who are
willing to chance sacrificing their careers and/or their reputations to champion
an unpopular idea? For an overview of the vaccine issue and how conflict
of interest has influenced the process, click
here.
December 13, 2003 -
Hear the Silence - A
forthcoming drama about the MMR controversy has angered manydoctors.
A general practitioner and two child health experts,who have all
seen a preview, explain why - journal article (BMJ)
December 12, 2003 The editor of Lancet on
Hearthe Silence
-
letter (BMJ)
December 8, 2003 - MMR
uptake increases slightly - A slight increase in the number of children
being given the measles, mumps and rubella vaccination has been recorded in
Scotland. - BBC
December 2003 -
New Hepatitis A Vaccine Efficacy May Last 21 Years - Few local side effects
(requires registration) - ePediatric News - "Based upon the slow yearly rate of
decline in anti-hepatitis A virus antibodies in the vaccinated children, it was
calculated using standard models that the median duration of protection will be
28.1 years. An estimated 95% of children will remain protected for 21.1 years.
The advantage of an aluminum-free hepatitis A vaccine over current vaccines that
rely upon aluminum hydroxide as an immunopotentiating adjuvant is markedly fewer
adverse effects at the injection site. The aluminum-free vaccine uses
reconstituted influenza virosomes as a carrier system for hepatitis A antigen."
Comment: Given
how questionable antibodies
are in terms of reflecting immunity, it is hard to trust any antibody
decay-rate- based extrapolation of a vaccine's duration of immunity.
Comment: Another reason
to avoid aluminum in vaccines is the
arguable
hypothesis that aluminum may in some way be connected to Alzheimer's.
December 2003 -
Black-White Gap in Pneumococcal Disease Closing - Prevnar led to a 92% drop
in the disease in black children from 1998 to 2002. Vaccine appears to be
reaching both groups (requires registration) - ePediatric News
December 11, 2003 - The
Meningococcal Vaccine -- Public Policy and Individual Choices
(full text requires subscription the first 6 months after publication) - journal
article (NEJM)
- "On December 11, 2002, a 12-year-old girl from suburban Philadelphiadied as a result of serogroup C meningococcal infection. Death
occurred within hours after the initial manifestation of theillness.
Her parents learned subsequently that a vaccine wasavailable that
might have prevented their daughter's death.They asked, 'Why didn't
we know about this vaccine?'"
December 6, 2003 - Events:
Maxvax is canceled - Officials cite nationwide shortage of flu vaccine -
Grand Forks Herald
December 11, 2003 -
Advocate Says Government Should Release Flu Shot Data
- www.newsmax.com - "A leading vaccine
safety and informed consent advocate is calling on federal health officials and
flu vaccine makers to be honest with the American people about the effectiveness
of this year's flu vaccine...Transcripts from the February 20 and March 18, 2003
meetings of the FDA Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee
(VRBPAC) reveal that health officials around the world knew the genetically
mutated Fujian strain was associated with significant morbidity and mortality
and that last year's vaccine showed little protection against it.
December 12, 2003 -
Miscalculations
Lead to Flu Vaccine Shortage - Fox News - "Last year, three manufacturers
made 95 million doses of the flu vaccine. Eighty million doses were used, and
companies were forced to eat the cost of the unused portions. The outcome was
costly with pharmaceutical giant Wyeth (search) dropping
out of producing vaccines this year, and the remaining two companies Aventis
Pasteur (search) and Chiron
Corp. (search)
hoping not to make the same mistake...The government does not pay for the extra
doses of flu vaccine. It works with drug companies to guess yearly demand based
on the previous year's use."
December 11, 2003 - ID
Biomedical Reports Positive Preclinical Data Against Variant Influenza Strains
- Life Science News - "Results
from pre-clinical experiments performed by ID Biomedical scientists and recently
published in the September 2003 issue of the peer reviewed journal, Vaccine,
provides evidence that nasal Proteosome(TM)- influenza subunit vaccines can
protect against infection by variant strains of influenza virus that have
'drifted' from the strain present in the vaccine...ID Biomedical is a
biotechnology company focused on the development of proprietary subunit vaccine
products, including those based on its Proteosome(TM) platform intranasal
adjuvant/delivery technology."
December 9, 2003 - Dog
helps boy cope with autism - The Globe and Mail - "Jamil Shah threw long
tantrums, and like thousands of other autistic children, could barely
communicate with his parents...These days, the 12-year-old is doing better. He
cuddles beside his canine companion, Sherlock, whenever he's upset, he's grown
aware of his surroundings, but mostly he's more affectionate."
December 9, 2003 - Students
with autism are moving to Kalamazoo -
www.woodtv.com/ - "The
number of autistic children in one West Michigan county is on the rise.
Kalamazoo County has seen an increase of more than 300 percent over the last
decade. One reason for that could be a special classroom at Croyden Avenue
School."
Comment: Or perhaps it is an actual rise in the number of children with
autism in Kalamazoo County.
December 12, 2003 - Notice to
Readers: Request for Information About Acute Encephalopathy Associated with
Influenza Virus Infection in U.S. Children - CDC via MMWR - "Reports
of influenza-associated encephalopathy have been uncommon in the United States (3,4).
To determine if a similar pattern is occurring in the United States, CDC is
requesting information on any case meeting certain criteria. The criteria
include a person aged <18 years with altered mental status or personality change
lasting >24 hours and occurring within 5 days of onset of an acute febrile
respiratory illness, laboratory or rapid diagnostic test evidence of acute
influenza virus infection associated with the respiratory illness, and diagnosis
of the condition in the United States."
Comment:
Might at least some of this be
Reye's syndrome,
which can be confused with encephalitis? If so, and in those cases, might
the "influenza-associated encephalopathy" be treatment related, i.e., caused by
treating the flu with aspirin, rather than a direct consequence of the flu?
December 9, 2003 - CDC
to monitor children's flu complications - AP via CNN - "A new concern is the
rise of a common drug-resistant staph infection that is complicating efforts to
treat children with the flu, an official with the Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention said Monday...Dr. Tim Uyeki, epidemiologist with the influenza
branch of CDC, said that some children have died from the staph infections -- a
phenomenon the CDC has not seen before."
Comment: Why
would children with flu suddenly be dying from staph infections? Has
something happened to impair their immune systems and make them more vulnerable
to these infections than normally would occur when they have the flu? Or
is there something about this particular flu that makes them weaker in a way
that, for the first time, makes them extremely vulnerable to staph?
December 9, 2003 - Flu
a serious threat to kids - This season, more are suffering from severe
complications - AP via Tallahassee Democrat
December 5, 2003 - Flu
likely cause of 2 more deaths - State's outbreak already tops previous 2
seasons combined - Daily Camera - "If
confirmed, it would mean at least seven flu deaths in Colorado this season, she
said. All of them have been children."
December 8, 2003 - 170,000
dogs killed in southern China due to rise in rabies - USAgNet - "The number
of rabies infections in Guangdong jumped from 12 cases in 1996 to 115 cases
between January to August this year, the China News Service (CNS) said Monday."
December 4, 2003 - Researchers
Use Crippled Poliovirus To Attack Brain Cancer - Duke University Medical
News - "In
the study, the modified poliovirus rapidly killed cancer cells derived from
primary brain tumors as well as cells derived from breast and colon cancer
metastases -- all within a matter of four to six hours. In fact, polio is known
to be one of the quickest killers of infected host cells, producing
approximately a thousand additional infectious viral units per infected cell, he
said."
Comment: Does exposure to wild
poliovirus have the same effect?
Given that
most (95%) of those exposed to polio experience no
apparent symptoms at all, and another 4-8% only mild symptoms, perhaps there is
some advantage to allowing circulation of the virus while at the same time
determining who those few are that get serious illness and why they are
vulnerable to serious polio disease. Perhaps there could then be a more
targeted strategy.
Comment: It is well established
and widely accepted that
tonsillectomy and
injections
(including antibiotic injection) predispose a person to either bulbar or
paralytic polio. It is unknown to what, if any, extent the decline in
tonsillectomies and antibiotic injections caused or contributed to the decline
in polio. Just as it is unknown to what, if any, extent the polio vaccine caused
or contributed to the decline in polio.
December 8, 2003 - Post-Polio
Syndrome - Ivanhoe Newswire - "Polio is a disease that many people dont
think about anymore, but for many polio survivors, the disease is something they
cant forget. Approximately 300,000 polio survivors will experience their polio
symptoms again, decades after they had the disease."
December 5, 2003 - FdL
whooping cough cases rise - Fon Du Lac Reporter - "County Health Officer
Diane Cappozzo said people who are infected or live with a family member
diagnosed with pertussis have been told to remain at home in isolation through a
five-day course of antibiotics...While no official quarantine is in place,
Cappozzo said officials are strongly recommending both children and adults stay
home. An official quarantine would require legal enforcement and posting
placards on peoples houses."
Other diseases/conditions (some already in the vaccine pipeline)
December 11, 2003 -
Husband's
long battle to prove wife's innocence - Times Online -
"After her eight-week trial last year, Mrs Cannings told an interviewer she had
done everything in my power to show the jury what I was like as a person; a
person known to family and friends as a devoted mother. Yet her performance as a
witness was eclipsed by those of expert prosecution witnesses who damned her on
the basis of statistics."
December 11, 2003 - Unexplained deaths
fall but claim 7 lives a week
- Times Online - "According
to the Foundation for the Study of Infant Deaths (FSID), 89 per cent of all cot
deaths in England and Wales occur in babies aged under six months. Boys appear
to be at higher risk than girls."
Comment: Boys are also at a
higher risk for autism.
December 12, 2003 -
Alarm as cot deaths
double in Scotland - Evening Times Online - "Over
the next two years experts are to review many Scots cot death cases to try to
learn more about Sudden Infant Death Syndrome."
Comment: There
are those, on the other hand, who believe that HIV is
not the cause
of AIDS.
December 10, 2003 - Targeted
Genetics targets AIDS: Testing under way on single-shot vaccine - The
Seattle Times - "AIDS kills 300 people an hour, but in the
past two decades, only one biotech company has come close to developing a
preventive vaccine...But another biotech Seattle-based Targeted Genetics
plus an academic research center and a nonprofit institution backed by the Bill
& Melinda Gates Foundation are announcing today they are trying another
technique."
December 9, 2003 - HIV - tailored
to fit (requires registration) - BioMedNet - "New research on HIV shows that
the virus mutates throughout its genome to evade each particular individual's
immune system, report Australian immunologists. The results could have important
implications for vaccine design, they say."
December 12, 2003 - Boom,
or bust? - Hundreds of millions of dollars are pouring into US biodefence
research. You might expect scientists working on infectious diseases to be
unequivocally delighted. But things aren't that simple, says Erika Check.
(requires registration) - drug discovery @
www.nature.com
December 8, 2003 - Health
Danger Depends On Access - Doctors say the uninsured are a risk to public
health - St. Petersburg Times via
www.theledger.com - "The worry: Because the uninsured are less likely to
seek prompt care, they would be more likely to spread disease in an epidemic.
While the chances of such an epidemic or bioterrorist attack might be remote,
doctors say that ultimately, the barriers to getting uninsured people cared for
could help infection spread further and faster than it otherwise would."
December 8, 2003 - Holyrood
accused of toeing Westminster line on hepatitis C infection - The Scotsman -
"Although the Executive has
suggested payouts to those infected, patients say the amounts are derisory and
far below those recommended by an expert committee chaired by Lord Ross...They
have accused the health committee of letting them down by deciding to stop
considering their cause, which includes demands for an independent inquiry. They
are also angry the decision was taken in private."
December 6, 2003 - Tiny
Bubbles - Vesicles that cells spit out are implicated in cancer and AIDS -
Science News
December 5, 2003 - Auckland
Asthma Achievers Celebrated - Asthma and Respiratory Foundation of New
Zealand via www.scoop.co.nz - "Six
Aucklanders are being celebrated today in recognition of their individual
achievements in meeting and overcoming the extra challenges they face because of
a respiratory condition."
December 8, 2003 - Breathing new
life into natural killers (requires registration) - BioMedNet - "A novel
approach to the treatment of immunological disorders, which harnesses the
activity of so-called natural killer T cells, could make an important
contribution to the treatment of a range of diseases including diabetes, report
US immunologists."
December 12, 2003 - Microbes chill out
(requires registration) - BioMedNet - "There's something lurking in the corner
of the kitchen - it's square and white and produces an ominous buzzing noise ...
is it dangerous? A new hypothesis from French gastroenterologists suggests that
the seemingly harmless refrigerator could habor bacteria that are implicated in
Crohn's disease."
Big
pharma, research conduct, medical conduct, conflict of interest, ethics, FDA,
oversight, approval process, warnings
Comment: There is
simply no excuse for this. Is it laziness? Is it misplaced faith in, and
an over-reliance on, drugs to solve the problems caused by their own bad
behavior? If so, have they not noticed that another "bad behavior", i.e.,
over- and incorrect use of antibiotics, has severely limited antibiotic
usefulness and may have even
destroyed the "miracle"?
December 11, 2003 - Medical
expert faces inquiry - Times Online - "SIR ROY
MEADOW, the expert whose evidence helped to convict at least three mothers of
murdering their children, first came to prominence in the late Seventies...He
claimed that many parents deliberately harmed their babies in order to draw
attention to themselves, the condition known as Münchausen syndrome by proxy."
Comment: Isn't it about time we began seriously
questioning the "experts"? Isn't it about time we re-examined the power we
have given them over our lives? How many lives have been ruined because of our
blind faith in them? How many families have been ripped apart? (For
more on the question of possible false imprisonment due to shaken baby syndrome,
go to the
Online SBS Conference at
www.redflagsdaily.com.)
December 10, 2003 -
Group Seeks Toss of Patient Privacy Rules- The Washington Post - "A group of doctors and patient
advocates asked a federal judge Wednesday to throw out new health care privacy
rules, claiming they're inadequate...The federal regulations, which took effect
in April, were designed to tighten patient privacy protections. But the group
said they instead leave patients powerless to stop disclosures of sensitive
information."
December 8, 2003 - Even
giants like Merck struggling with hard times - AP via Buffalo News - "The
problems besetting pharmaceutical giant Merck & Co. also plague most of its
competitors: falling profits, patent expirations, generic competition, the lack
of new blockbuster drugs and pressures to make medicines more affordable...But
the contrast to the heady days and double-digit profit growth of the 1990s is
particularly striking at Merck, which has fallen in just a few years from the
world's biggest drugmaker to No. 3 as competitors merged and leapfrogged
ahead...'Size is not important in this industry. (Revenue) growth is'...."
December 5, 2003 - Hospital
faces another abuse claim - CP via
http://cnews.canoe.ca - "Another case of alleged abuse at a long-term care
facility came to light Friday after a patient complained about poor treatment
that included being bedridden and deprived of liquids."
December 5, 2003 - We
should give a monkey's - The government is backing research on non-human
primates for economic reasons, to the detriment of public health - The Guardian,
UK - "Experimenting on monkeys in the hope of unlocking the secrets of the human
brain is an exercise in futility. The most dramatic differences between humans
and other primates are in the brain. Our brain is four times larger than that of
a chimpanzee, which is four times larger than that of a macaque. Biochemical
pathways in the human brain are unique. Gene expression in our brain is
dramatically different from that of the chimpanzee...Yet at British
universities, including Oxford, Cambridge, Manchester and London, macaques and
marmosets are still used as models of human brain function. This is despite the
fact that human brains can now be studied non-invasively using high-tech
scanners."
December 12, 2003 - Antidepressant
use in children questioned - Recent warnings of suicide risk associated with
antidepressant use in children have highlighted the lack of understanding of
paediatric depression (requires registration) - drug discovery @
www.nature.com
December 12, 2003 - Second-hand
smoke may harm pets - Many refuse to accept findings/Pet fur traps smoke
particles - The New York Times via The Toronto Star
December 12, 2003 - Period
peace - A new pill going on sale in the US gives women just four periods a
year. But is it safe to staunch the flow, asks Jennifer Fried - The Guardian, UK
December 8, 2003 - Too
big for our belts - Here in the land of plenty, talking about obesity -
whether in grownups, kids or pets - has become a national obsession. - St.
Petersburg Times
December 6, 2003 - One
of the N crowd - So, you've won a Nobel Prize and all that's left is to
revel in fame and funding? Not quite. Some scientists thrive, but many find the
going gets tougher. - An edited extract from the book The Road to Stockholm -
The Sydney Morning Herald
DISCLAIMER: All
information, data, and material contained, presented, or provided here is for
general information purposes only and is not to be construed as reflecting the
knowledge or opinions of the publisher, and is not to be construed or intended
as providing medical or legal advice. The decision whether or not to vaccinate
is an important and complex issue and should be made by you, and you alone, in
consultation with your health care provider.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
Sandy's Scandals Column
Past and current Scandals
- columns by Sandy Gottstein (aka Mintz)*
* ►February 8, 2010 - Inovio
Biomedical Cervical Cancer Therapeutic Vaccine Generates Dose-Related
Immune Response in Clinical Trial - Inovio via BusinessWire
via Technology Marketing Corporation - "VGX-3100 is a DNA vaccine
targeting the E6 and E7 proteins of human papillomavirus (HPV) types 16
and 18 and is delivered via in vivo electroporation. Similar to
previously reported data from the initial lowest dose cohort of this
phase I trial, the vaccine was found to be generally safe and well
tolerated. While previously reported data showed significant cellular
and humoral immune responses, data from this second, intermediate dose
group highlighted a significantly increased and dose-related immune
response specific to the antigens targeted by the vaccine."..."While
recent HPV preventive vaccines have been successful in protecting
against infections that may lead to cervical cancer, Inovio's
therapeutic vaccine targets the millions of women already infected with
HPV and is intended to treat pre-cancerous cells and cervical cancer
caused by this virus. Current vaccines do not serve this group of
women," Dr. Kim added."
* ►February 6, 2010 - Autism
Findings Retracted
- The New American - "Actress Holly Robinson Peete remembers, 'When my
son was two-and-a-half, he was just recovering from an ear infection
and had been on antibiotics, therefore his immune system was
suppressed. He had already missed several appointments for his
vaccination so his pediatrician wanted to catch him up on all of them
in the same day. Althrough I asked if he’d consider waiting or breaking
up the cocktail, which contains three viruses, he laughed me out of the
office and belittled me. I firmly believe that it took my son to a
place of no return and his body could not handle it. He had a violent
reaction with convulsions and then he stopped talking and slipped into
a silence. He no longer said, 'Hi, Mommy,' he no longer responded to
his name and he no longer made eye contact.”