Luck appears to be the one distinct advantage the United States
has over many other countries affected by the unfolding medical
mystery of SARS, several of the nation's top doctors said yesterday.
With just 41 confirmed cases of severe acute respiratory
syndrome, U.S. medical officials worry that Americans might be
lulled into a false sense of security. They cautioned it would be a
dangerous mistake to assume the contagious virus causing SARS will
not still strike in larger numbers here.
As evidence, they pointed to two SARS hot spots -- Toronto and
Hong Kong. In those cities, sophisticated medicine and strong public
health systems -- on par with the expertise in major U.S. cities --
were not enough to contain the rapid spread of the disease.
"We haven't had the kind of long chains of transmission that
we've seen in some other countries, but there is no reason why that
couldn't happen here," Julie Gerberding, head of the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention, said on "Fox News Sunday."
"It is not under control right now," said Anthony S. Fauci,
director of the infectious-disease division at the National
Institutes of Health. "The important thing is to get it under
control and to prevent that domino effect of expansion from one
contact to another, which we've seen in a very, very serious way in
Hong Kong and other Asian countries."
The new respiratory ailment first appeared in southeastern China
in November. Initial confusion about the strange pneumonia, followed
by widespread effort by Communist Party leaders to conceal the
outbreak, gave the virus a big jump on physicians in Asia and
Canada. The early cases abroad and a mid-March alert by the World
Health Organization put the United States in a better position to
respond.
"We were fortunate enough to be just ahead of the curve," Fauci
said on ABC's "This Week."
Experts say they believe SARS is transmitted most easily through
close human contact, often from sneezing or coughing. But some
laboratory analysis and several cases suggest it may survive on
surfaces for several hours, making it possible to spread the germ
simply by touching objects.
In Hong Kong and Toronto, medical workers have been hit hard by
the disease, and health systems are in danger of being overwhelmed,
said Jeffrey P. Koplan, a physician at Emory University in Atlanta
who just spent a week in Hong Kong.
"No matter how talented the health workers are and what resources
are available, an event like this quickly taxes it to the extreme,"
said Koplan, who was Gerberding's predecessor at the CDC. "There is
nothing that has happened in Toronto that couldn't happen anywhere
in the United States."
Fauci and Koplan expressed concern about the many unknown aspects
of SARS, particularly how it can be spread, how long individuals are
contagious and whether someone can transmit the virus without
displaying symptoms. Those uncertainties have meant that in Hong
Kong virtually every patient arriving at a hospital is treated as a
potential SARS case, which reduces the chances of missing SARS
carriers but adds to the burdens on doctors and nurses.
"It's very difficult to sustain this level of intensity and
concern and hard work for such a long period of time," Koplan said,
noting that Hong Kong hospitals have been battling SARS for two
months already.
Worldwide, SARS appears to kill about 6 percent of those known to
be infected, Gerberding said. But with so many critically ill
patients, she predicted the death toll would rise. SARS has infected
at least 4,800 people and killed 293, according to the latest
figures collected by the WHO. U.S. officials are monitoring more
than 200 possible cases.
Because there is no known treatment or vaccine, health officials
say their main tool in fighting SARS is isolating patients and
quarantining others who have been exposed to the coronavirus.
"We know that our containment can work, but we do have to be
vigilant about every step in the process," Gerberding said. "And
that means detecting people at the earliest possible moment."
Fauci, citing an executive order recently signed by President
Bush, noted that the federal government does have the power to
isolate and quarantine infected patients arriving in the United
States from abroad. But state health officers and legal scholars say
that order does not extend to people already in the United States or
in large groups, such as an apartment building, congregation or
hospital.
Last week, WHO officials issued an advisory that people should
postpone travel to Toronto, citing evidence that the city had
inadvertently "exported" a handful of SARS cases to other countries.
Robert G. Webster, an infectious-disease specialist at St. Jude
Children's Research Hospital in Memphis who accompanied Koplan to
Hong Kong, said that despite the harsh economic consequences of that
advisory, he supports the WHO decision.
"Show us it is under control," he said in response to complaints
by Canadian leaders. "They must demonstrate they have stopped the
spreading."