The Environmental Working
Group claimed that DuPont violated federal law by failing to turn
over a document in 1981 showing the risks of perfluorooctanoic acid,
or C8, a chemical used to manufacture Teflon.
Teflon is a widely
available household product used to keep clothing such as jackets
dry or to prevent food from sticking to pots and pans.
"They obviously had no
intention of ever turning this over to the EPA," said Richard Wiles,
a vice president of the advocacy group. "This is very damning
evidence. It's not surprising to us that they withheld it, and who
knows what else they've withheld?"
The group asked the
Environmental Protection Agency (news
-
web sites) to investigate and determine if the company broke
federal law by failing to immediately disclose the health impacts of
the chemical.
The EPA said it was
reviewing the document and did not have an immediate comment.
Wilmington,
Delaware-based DuPont denied the allegations by the Environmental
Working Group that the company violated the Toxic Substance Control
Act by not reporting information about C8.
The environmental group
cited a 1981 internal study by DuPont that measured the blood levels
of seven women who worked at the company's Teflon plant in West
Virginia. All had detectable levels of the chemical in their bodies,
according to the document.
CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT
The DuPont study also
said one woman gave birth to a child with an eye and tear duct
defect, and another employee bore a child with a nostril and eye
defect. That same year, DuPont reassigned 50 women from the plant to
reduce their exposure to the chemical, the Environmental Working
Group said.
Residents near the West
Virginia plant have filed a class-action lawsuit against DuPont over
contamination of area water supplies. The DuPont report on C8 came
to light in the course of that lawsuit.
"There is no evidence or
data that demonstrates (C8) causes adverse human health effects,
including developmental or reproductive effects, in any segment of
the human population," said Robert Rickard, director of DuPont's
Haskell Laboratory for Health and Environmental Sciences.
DuPont said the company
recorded the women's low-level exposure but did not conduct a formal
study evaluating C8 or its effect on human health.
The federal Toxic
Substance Control Act only requires companies to report information
when the public is at risk, DuPont said, and it added there were no
adverse effects to humans exposed to the chemical.
DuPont said its records
showed one birth defect, but added there was "no indication" it was
linked to exposure to C8.
The Teflon chemical C8 is
part of a broader family called perfluorochemicals. Tests have shown
that C8 and similar chemicals can cause liver damage and
reproductive problems in rats, according to scientists.
The Environmental Working Group said laboratory studies have
linked exposure to perfluorochemicals to cancer, hypothyroidism and
brain damage.
In 2000, 3M Corp. pulled its stain repellent Scotchgard from the
market after the EPA expressed concern that a sister chemical to C8
posed serious health risks. 3M has since stopped making all
perfluorochemicals.
The EPA last September began a priority review of C8 under the
Toxic Chemicals Control Act, which can be used to ban chemicals that
can lead to health problems or defects.
An EPA official said the agency planned to release a final
version of its report on Monday.
In a draft copy released last month, the EPA found that C8
accumulates in the blood system and has toxic chemicals that pose a
risk for childbearing women. The agency urged further study of the
chemical's impact on humans.
For its part, DuPont said that the EPA document was a preliminary
draft and that data recently shared with the government support the
chemical's safety.